Shillelagh Druid or Shillelagh Nature-Bound Magus?


Advice


So... I have been working on my Concordance of the Elements character, and plan on making them either a Melee focused Druid or Magus - both themes heavily inspired off of Celtic/Gaelic Lore. I've been spending a lot of time trying to make the Melee focused Druid work, and have only played him three times thus far.

Background Information:
The first time was... Less than stellar. I had taken Weapon Proficiency (Lance) with Eidolon Mount. That was my first encounter with: "You're too large to charge!" It didn't help that I was rushed with my character, so my Elemental Allies were unfinished.

It wasn't until the second game (when I scrapped the Mounted Combat concept) when I had more than a basic idea of what the character was going to be like. This time, I had taken Weapon Proficiency (Madu) with Two Weapon Fighting, using a Masterwork Spear (+4/1d6+3) and a Madu Shield (+3/1d6+4).

It... Didn't go to well... Unfortunately, Nixie (the Water Eidolon) had Improved Unarmed Combat instead of Dirty Fighting, Sidhe the Wind Eidolon was also not helpful due to having been taken control of due to being a Wind Elemental. Uru the Earth Elemental was my next best thing - because I wasn't going to summon Eldur my Fire Eidolon in the middle of the ocean. Both of them were weakened due to the elemental disturbance.

It wasn't until the third time I used Ulrik when I felt that I was actually doing something. I picked up a Quarterstaff and used Shillelagh as my primary offensive spell. Used the spell in the beginning of combat and ran around slapping people in the face with (+5/2d6+6) 2handed or (+3/2d6+5|+3/2d6+3) two-weapon fighting. I gave my Water Elemental the Dirty Fighting feat, and it was SOOOOooo much better to grab with a +9 while flanking. The Earth Elemental was good because it helped us climb down a cliff with its climb speed. Wind and Fire still haven't have too much limelight yet, but they're progressing slowly.

I was thinking of continuing this character... Until I found the Nature-Bound Magus and found out that it stacks with the Staff Magus. My question: Is it work trading Magus Arcana for Druid Spells while you progress? (Starting with One level 0 and 1, and then getting a new one each time you get new level spells).

Current Builds:
Druid Build:

Ulrik Talandi, the Spirit Caller:
Archetype: Elemental Ally
Stats: (Str: 16) (Dex: 16) (Con: 12) (Int: 8) (Wis:14) (Cha: 10)
Human: Bonus Feat, Skilled
Feats: Two-Weapon Fighting, Weapon Focus (Quaterstaff)
Traits: Scholar of Balance (Faction), Monk Weapon Skill (Quarterstaff)
Attacks:
* Quarterstaff 2H (+5/1d4+6)
* Quaterstaff TWF (+3/1d4+5)(+3/1d4+3)
* Shillelagh 2H (+5/2d6+6)
* Shillelagh TWF (+3/2d6+5)(+3/2d6+3)


Nixie, the Spirit of Water:
Eidolon: Elemental (Water)
Base Form: Aberrant
Feats: Dirty Fighting
Immunity: Sleep, Paralyze, Cold

Uru, the Spirit of Earth:
Eidolon: Elemental (Earth)
Base Form: Serpentine - Small
Feats: Skill Focus (Stealth)
Immunity: Sleep, Paralyze, Acid

Sidhe, the Spirit of Wind:
Eidolon: Elemental (Wind)
Base Form: Quadruped
Feats: Toughness
Immunity: Sleep, Paralyze, Electricity

Eldur, the Spirit of Fire:
Eidolon: Elemental (Fire)
Base Form: Biped
Feats: Weapon Focus (Slam)
Immunity: Sleep, Paralyze, Fire
+=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=+
Magus Build:
Cedric Talandi, Friend of Fey:
Archetype: Nature-Bonded / Staff Magus
Stats: (Str: 16) (Dex: 16) (Con: 12) (Int: 14) (Wis:8) (Cha: 10)
Human: Bonus Feat, Heart of the Fey
Feats: Combat Casting, Weapon Focus (Quarterstaff)
Traits: Arcane Temper (Magic), Monk Weapon Skill (Quarterstaff)
Attacks:
* Quarterstaff (+5/1d4+5)
* Shillelagh (+5/2d6+5)


Spriggen, the Flower Sprite:
Familiar: Flowering Lattice
Archetypes: Figment, Sage
Special Abilities: Bountiful Fruits, Pollen

+=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=+
That is the crunch of it all. Ulfrik is more rough and gruff with his Elementals not having much development (I suck with IRL RP), but Cedric seems like he would be fun with his little Spriggen (Being a Figment, I already have ideas of what I can do).

What do you all think?

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Advice / Shillelagh Druid or Shillelagh Nature-Bound Magus? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.