
Colette Brunel |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |
What is the point of being an animal totem barbarian? You downgrade from a two-handed weapon (any weapons, even backup ranged weapons) in exchange for d10 damage unarmed attacks.
Even then, why is there a difference between animal totems? As it stands, the cat is the objectively best totem, since it offers a d10 weapon and an agile d8 weapon. The bear comes in second place yet is still objectively inferior, and everything else is plain worse.
Why does even Animal Rage need to have objectively inferior and objectively superior options? The cat, the deer, and the wolf are the best options for animal rage, with the deer receiving the best deal.

Niels Christensen |
Theres a few things going for it but on average it is probably worse or alot more hassle than to be a more generic 2h barbarian. The totems first are slightly different from each other based on the resistance they eventually apply, and the same goes for the animals, different attacks are piercing slashing or bludgeoning for fighting weak or resistant enemies. Another benefit is some of these attacks are agile for some secondary attack work or don't use up a hand so they can be used for maneuvers or attacks when your hands are free. Also later transformations can give you a few more perks like movement or scent ect.
While its not great, the other totems don't seem great either or greatly balanced for eachother, and rage totem will probably be really strong when theres more splat books but right now also seems weak just because there is so few options outside of the totem powers.
Potential interesting things about animal totem though, dip into fighter for duel strike/duelwielding abilies. Does holding a 1d12 greatsword and having a d10 bite attack count for having two weapons ? Otherwise two d10s for higher 1h damage than most other classes can currently get.
Animal hide gives 2 ac over barbarian during rage, or would have if you weren't still untrained in unarmored defense so you are still the same ac and even worse outside of raging and fatigued.
Doing terrible dipping into fighter and then Grey Maiden can eventually let you use that d10 "1h" with a shield, though it would probably still be better to just get the dueling feat from fighter for +2ac.

![]() |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

I find it especially odd that animal companions have so many unique abilities written in the book that players have no way to grab. Giving them to the animal totem barbarian would be a great way to develop it (bear hug, flyby attack, cat pounce, darting attack, gallop, constrict, and wolf trip all seem like cool things a shape-shifting Barbarian could utilize).