Impossible to get the first desired reward


Pathfinder Society

Silver Crusade

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Note: Ok, this is going to end up sounding kinda whiney, but it really isn't meant to be that. I'm more trying to determine if this is a common issue and maybe discuss if there is some sort of potential fix that could be considered.

Rarely have the purchasable items on chronicle sheets been something I wanted before I could just purchase it anyway. But a few times, I have played or run a module at low tier. Looking at the chronicle sheet there has been something on the high tier that the PC might have actually purchased (scroll, poison, or partially charged wand). Slightly annoying, but not that big a deal.

However, recently it was a more aggravating instance. I have a character that is built around using a certain exotic weapon. He's pretty amazing with it and has surprised many players at the table even when low level playing in the high tier.
Now avoiding spoilers, I played a scenario in low tier. There is that exact exotic weapon with special powers that there is no other way to gain in PFS except this chronicle sheet and this character would love to purchase it even if its limit use isn't really worth the cost. But it is only listed in the high tier.

Now as I understand the rules, there is absolutely no way to get the item. Can't have 2 of the same chronicle sheet on a character, so I can't use a replay or GM the scenario. According to the others at the table, I can't even decide to have played for no credit (I wasn't necessary to make a legal table) and wait until the PC is higher level. The odds of me ever playing another PC that uses the same exotic weapon is essentially nil.

After the scenario, I'm looking over the chronicle sheet. "Wow! Look at this X. It's so kool! He's gotta have that no matter the price." (I think the first time I've really had even close to that reaction for the list of items which can be purchased.) Nope. No way. Not possible. grr... Please believe me, I'm really not someone who wants the surprise of a scenario spoiled before I play it. However, I really wish I had waited to play that scenario (I had 2 others in low tier) until I could play or GM it at high tier.

Now I know there are many of you that have played/GM'd a whole lot more scenarios than I have. I'm told that some have played them all in standard mode and even getting close to that in core mode. So my questions are:
1) Is this an isolated incident or does this happen often enough that others consider it an issue?
2) Any ideas on how to work around this issue?

5/5 5/55/55/5

1 person marked this as a favorite.

A boon "unlocked power" where you can bump something from the low tier loot to the high tier loot would be pretty neat.

Grand Lodge 5/5

1 person marked this as a favorite.

This sounds like fertile ground for a con boon as there have been others along this line line.

Silver Crusade

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Hmm... Personally, I wouldn't be thrilled for a con only boon as a solution. Between work, family, and money I'm lucky to make it to one con a year. That makes my odds of getting the solution pretty low. But I suppose then there would at least be a chance.

Grand Lodge 4/5

2 people marked this as a favorite.

The only way I know of right now to handle this is to GM the scenario with another character who is in high tier, and find one of the con boons that allows transfer of items to another PC. Highly unsatisfying, but that's all I have. :(

Scarab Sages 4/5

Morrolan de'Morcaine wrote:
Hmm... Personally, I wouldn't be thrilled for a con only boon as a solution. Between work, family, and money I'm lucky to make it to one con a year. That makes my odds of getting the solution pretty low. But I suppose then there would at least be a chance.

Hopefully with the revised regional boon support, access to boons won't be as limited going forward. Ask your local Venture Officers to look into participating and setting it up for your local game days.

Silver Crusade

Steven Schopmeyer wrote:
... and find one of the con boons that allows transfer of items to another PC. ...

Had not heard of that one. Which one pays for the items, the giving or receiving PC? How hard is it to get that con boon?

5/5 5/55/55/5

Morrolan de'Morcaine wrote:


Had not heard of that one. Which one pays for the items, the giving or receiving PC? How hard is it to get that con boon?

The boon trading thread should have one, you'd probably need 1 or 2 lesser boons to trade for it.

Grand Lodge 4/5 **** Venture-Captain, California—Sacramento

The con boon I am aware of specifically transfers allies and intelligent weapons. Is there one that transfers non intelligent items?

The boon transfers access to the item, the receiving character pays to buy it.

I would totally second the call to have a boon that lets you "uncross off" an item on a sheet.

Shadow Lodge 4/5 5/5 RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 8

1) Is this an isolated incident or does this happen often enough that others consider it an issue?
2) Any ideas on how to work around this issue?

---------
1) I'd say it's a fairly corner case. Typically one of two things happens. Either you play a game with boon X that works on character Y, but you played character Z for it. Fortunately, you can GM that game and apply it to character Y. The other case is that boon X is perfect for character Y, but is the wrong level (typically a 1-5 boon but Y is level 6+). Rarer still that it's your circumstance. Because if you had played that game with any other character, you could have later GM'd it and applied credit to the appropriate character.

2) Suggestions of a boon that unlocks the higher tier are great, and as others have said, the new RSP program aims to get con boons into the hands of non-con goers. So it may be a situation where there'll be an easier solution to this going forward. The other less obvious fix is to GM more than you play, then you can see the boons coming. The downside is that you'll never be able to really contribute when it comes to investigative scenarios.

Spoiler:
If you provide further details in a spoiler or PM regarding the scenario and the weapon in question, I might have some other insights.


Is this an item that can be purchased or made once the appropriate Fame level is reached?

Sczarni 5/5 5/55/5 ***

It's unique to the Chronicle, if it's the one I'm thinking of.

Silver Crusade

2 people marked this as a favorite.

No, it can not be otherwise made or purchased in any way that I know of so far.

if you really want to know:

It is the timeworn monowhip in #6-20, Returned to Sky.

Shadow Lodge 4/5 5/5 RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 8

Morrolan de'Morcaine wrote:

No, it can not be otherwise made or purchased in any way that I know of so far.

** spoiler omitted **

Spoiler:

As cool as that item is, note this regarding it.

"Activating a monowhip is a move action; once activated, the whip consumes power incredibly quickly, at the rate of 1 charge per round."

The timeworn whip on the chronicle only comes with 7 charges. So you'd effectively be spending 24,500 gp on basically a single use item.
So it may not be a bad thing that you missed this item. It feels... not very good for its cost.

Grand Lodge 5/5 *

I remember this complaint coming up locally about a different scenario and it's cool item being high tier only.

This one:
Scions of the Sky Key 1: On Sharrowsmith's Trail
Sharrowsmith's Handy Haversack

Sczarni 5/5 5/55/5 ***

Ha! I guess we're all thinking of different high tier exotic weapons.

I'll just mention the type of Weapon:
Tetsubo

Grand Lodge 4/5

Thankfully, that one is NOT missed out on my tengu cleric.

Nefreet:
Hikori is listed under All Subtiers, so it doesn't matter that I marked my GM chronicle down to 500 and applied it at 1st. :)

Scarab Sages 4/5

Steven Schopmeyer wrote:

Thankfully, that one is NOT missed out on my tengu cleric.

** spoiler omitted **

I'm looking at that one for my

Spoiler:
Yamatsumi worshipping Tetsubo wielding Nagaji Bloodrager who was partially inspired by that scenario. I might even burn a GM star to actually play it with him, instead of just applying GM credit. A recent 7-11 also had some similar elements included that might make me want to replay it with him.

Sovereign Court 4/5 5/5 ** Venture-Lieutenant, Netherlands—Leiden

Ferious Thune wrote:
Steven Schopmeyer wrote:

Thankfully, that one is NOT missed out on my tengu cleric.

** spoiler omitted **

I'm looking at that one for my

** spoiler omitted **

Might want to check out the First Mother's Fang nagaji cavalier archetype in Blood of the Beast. The synergy with that scenario is insaaaane.

4/5 5/5 **** Venture-Captain, Massachusetts—Boston Metro

Steven Schopmeyer wrote:

Thankfully, that one is NOT missed out on my tengu cleric.

** spoiler omitted **

That item is heavily dependent on GM fiat. As written its really hard to tell how you are supposed to get the item but I know when I GM'd it both tables had different interpretations of how to give out that item and both were completely valid in how to read that scenario.

Spoiler:
As I believe its supposed to be run now that I looked closely at it the Tetsubu is kind of a consolidation prize for not getting the really good boon. As written you effectively have to steal the Tetsubu from her. I didn't interpret it that way/missed that part but still its a valid interpretation.

Shadow Lodge 4/5

2 people marked this as a favorite.

Which was irrelevant to my case.

For those that avoid the fight and thus might be considered to not have access to it, I would refer to page 12 of the guide, which the spirit of says the party should not be punished for succeeding.

Silver Crusade

Walter Sheppard wrote:
Morrolan de'Morcaine wrote:

No, it can not be otherwise made or purchased in any way that I know of so far.

** spoiler omitted **

** spoiler omitted **

Oh, I agree that it really isn't worth the cost. But in-character he definitely wants it regardless.

Scarab Sages 4/5

Lau Bannenberg wrote:
Ferious Thune wrote:
Steven Schopmeyer wrote:

Thankfully, that one is NOT missed out on my tengu cleric.

** spoiler omitted **

I'm looking at that one for my

** spoiler omitted **

Might want to check out the First Mother's Fang nagaji cavalier archetype in Blood of the Beast. The synergy with that scenario is insaaaane.

Off-topic archetype/scenario discussion:
I'm aware of that archetype, and it looks really nice. I want to keep this character pure Bloodrager if I can. Dipping cavalier for the archetype would give me the tetsubo proficiency for real. Right now he's got an Ioun stone to make it a martial weapon. The snake mount is also nice, but would be underpowered even if I took Boon Companion. I don't think I could take Horsemaster without more levels in Cavalier. Plus, eventually I'll be large when I rage. The tetsubo from the scenario is something I might buy for flavor. It's tough not to just go with Furious, though.

Really, I wanted to play that scenario with my Nagaji Monk, but he's already level 13. I ended up playing with my sczarni Magus who was really the wrong character to have her morality tested.

The Exchange 2/5

Walter Sheppard wrote:

1) Is this an isolated incident or does this happen often enough that others consider it an issue?

2) Any ideas on how to work around this issue?

Random idea: if you GM a scenario, you also unlock the high-tier items for purchase off the chronicle applied from playing the scenario.

Recording this neatly on the paperwork needs some thought.

Silver Crusade 4/5 5/55/55/5 RPG Superstar 2013 Top 8

brock, no the other one... wrote:
Random idea: if you GM a scenario, you also unlock the high-tier items for purchase off the chronicle applied from playing the scenario

Only if the character who receives credit is in the higher subtier.

Grand Lodge 4/5

As Michael says, you just have to make sure your character is in the subtier you would like them to receive when applying GM credit.

GM Credit Subtiers GtOP pg16:
The subtier for which a GM’s character receives credit depends on the character’s level. If a GM with a 1st-level rogue runs a Tier 1–5 scenario using Subtier 1–2, she takes a Subtier 1–2 Chronicle sheet for her 1st-level rogue. If she instead runs a Tier 1–5 scenario using Subtier 4–5, she still takes a Subtier 1–2 Chronicle sheet, as her PC clearly falls within the lower subtier.
A GM who receives a Chronicle sheet that indicates her character is between subtiers must always receive the Out-of-Subtier gold value and access to items and boons for the subtier at which the adventure was played.

Scarab Sages 4/5

1 person marked this as a favorite.

I think he was suggesting a change whereby you could, possibly instead of reviving a new chronicle, unlock higher tier rewards on an existing player chronicle by GMing the scenario. I don't think he was suggesting that's how it currently works.


1. It is a pretty isolated case
2. There are no work arounds for your problem.

The Exchange 2/5

Ferious Thune wrote:
I think he was suggesting a change whereby you could, possibly instead of reviving a new chronicle, unlock higher tier rewards on an existing player chronicle by GMing the scenario. I don't think he was suggesting that's how it currently works.

Exactly correct - a little extra bonus to tempt GMs, and to resolve this issue that has the effect of making people regret playing.

Shadow Lodge 4/5 5/5 RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 8

That sounds like a cool idea Brock, easily implemented as well. Maybe the folks over at SFS are listening in and can pilot such a change for us ;)

Community / Forums / Organized Play / Pathfinder Society / Impossible to get the first desired reward All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Pathfinder Society