Sharding: Can it do this?


Rules Questions


Talking about this:http://www.d20pfsrd.com/magic-items/magic-weapons/magic-weapon-special -abilities/sharding

Spoiler:
Price +2 bonus; Aura moderate conjuration; CL 10th

DESCRIPTION

Restriction This ability can be placed only on melee or thrown weapons.

The wielder of a sharding weapon can make a special ranged attack with the weapon in place of any melee attack. To do this, the wielder goes through the motion of throwing the weapon without releasing it. The weapon splits off a duplicate of itself that flies as if thrown by the wielder at the intended target. The duplicate gains a range increment of 10 feet for this purpose, but uses the same proficiency and otherwise functions the same as the original weapon. The duplicate vanishes after hitting or missing its target.

CONSTRUCTION REQUIREMENTS

Cost +2 bonus; Feats Craft Magic Arms and Armor; Spells major creation


From the PC: Weapon Master's Handbook

Now, my question is: Would Sharding enable an Investigator to apply Studied Combat/Strike to a ranged attack without Ranged Study? It uses a melee weapon that never leaves your hand...


Sharding 1st sentence wrote:
The wielder of a sharding weapon can make a special ranged attack with the weapon in place of any melee attack.
Sharding 3rd sentence wrote:
The weapon splits off a duplicate of itself that flies as if thrown by the wielder at the intended target.

I added the bolding, I think it pretty clearly says it works as a thrown weapon attack that avoids being a novel method of disarming oneself.

EDIT:
I should point out that since Melee weapons have higher crit chances and multipliers than weapons designed to be thrown (game design, not RW) this is actually a pretty darn good effect.

Scarab Sages

It makes a ranged attack, so you need ranged study.
Edit: Studied Combat and Studied strike never say melee weapon, they say melee attack. Since sharing explicitly uses ranged attacks, they would not work with studied combat.


Ah, thanks for helping clarify that folks. Too bad, but I see plenty of reason for you to be correct.

Daw, I had this flash through my mind "Porthios has found a way to disarm himself"...


1 person marked this as a favorite.

I read the thread as being about "sharting"

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Sharding: Can it do this? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rules Questions