| Jaçinto |
As the title says, how do these work?
We encountered a troop and it didn't make much sense at all. I get the point of it but they are just people. Why is it that attack nearest, from confusion, not cause any in fighting and just attack the party instead? This does not make sense. Does this mean any group of people can be called a troop and thus only count as one creature? You also can't target individuals in the group or separate them at all. Is there any clarification on this? Also, how would grease work if they count as a single creature? Do the people not in it also fall down since the troop counts as one creature? Again with create pit. This thing is kind of stupid.
| QuidEst |
By the rules, Confusion doesn't work well on them (at least, not any better than it does on any other single creature). The GM can change that, of course. Sure it doesn't make sense. That's why there's a GM. For something like the troop type, there's really no way the rules could have elegantly handled all the unusual edge cases that crop up around it.
Of course any arbitrary group of creatures can't just be called a troop and count as one creature, any more than an arbitrary collection of tiny creatures can't be called a swarm and count as one creature. You need to have enough of them, and the GM has to decide to use swarm stats, or in this case, troop stats.
And no, you can't target single individuals and separate them. Essentially, you could, but it wouldn't matter because there are still lots more. Thus, the rules simply prevent it from working as a simplification.
Grease works just fine because it's an area effect. If fail their check, the troop falls prone (essentially, enough people fell down for the group as a whole to be considered prone). It's similar to the ability to trip the troop if you have a spell that trips everything within an area. Sure, it's weird that it works while only covering a quarter of their area, but that would be true for any gargantuan creature. GM might rule you need to cover at least half their area or something like that, but it'd be a house rule unless I missed something.
Create Pit isn't large enough for the troop to fall into. Since the troop's movement allows it to move where an individual creature could move, presumably that just represents the creatures standing around the pit, avoiding falling in with the help of their allies. And again, one could view it as some falling in without making a substantial difference.
It's not stupid, it's just an abstraction. It leads to some unusual edge cases, but that's fine. If you don't like it, that's fine, because you're almost never going to run into a troop in a game.