As frequently happens my Orc PC fell under the influence of an enemy spellcaster last night, failing his save against Dominate Person despite a high d20 roll due to negative levels. While dominated the orc was commanded to do some things against his nature, and the DM granted an additional saving throw at +2 per the spell description. I spent a hero point for +8 but still failed the save since I was adjacent to an Anti-Paladin with Aura of Despair, which gives enemies within 10' a -2 on all saves. My primary question here is whether I should still qualify as an enemy when I've been Dominated by the Anti-Paladin's ally and master.
I ask not only to find out if I "should have" made that second save but in case such situations come up again in the future. That doesn't seem unlikely since Will saves are a notable weakness of this PC and while I'll be taking some steps to shore that up I'd expect to keep on getting Charmed, Confused, and Dominated pretty regularly since the PC has high AC and generally does pretty well in melee.