1) This is fairly reasonable.
2) The difference between scorpion whip and a normal whip is that the former has only a 10 foot reach, is a light weapon, and deals lethal damage like a normal weapon.
3) I think Dervish Dancing is a too much considering he can play rather safely and get ranged spellstrikes.
4) Can't they already do that?
I'd personally just consider scorpion whips as one-handed weapons so a strength build is more appealing.
Well, you could take Slashing Grace-Whip (feat from ACG playtest doc) which allows you to treat it as a one handed piercing weapon for Swashbuckler (also ACG) or Duelist.
|
I have not looked at that source yet. Can they do dex to damage?
In the playtest, no. However, there was strong developer hints that there would be an option for DEX to damage in the release of the book.
As for the scimitar/vs whip comparison, The scimitar had the better crit profile, which really helps spellstrike.
Whip has more control options and is safer, scimitar has more damage.
Whip needs more feats, so Scimitar is a smaller investment.
I think they are pretty balanced.
|
My DM for Kingmaker uses this feat:
You have learned how to use your agility to greater purpose in battle.
Prerequisites: Weapon Finesse, base attack bonus +1
Benefit: You may add your Dexterity modifier in place of your Strength modifier when wielding a light weapon or a weapon that gains the benefits of the Weapon Finesse feat (such as the Rapier) when determining additional damage inflicted upon a successful attack. This modifier to damage is not increased for two-handed weapons, but is not reduced for off-hand weapons.
I don't know if he got it from somewhere, or he made it up.
I have not looked at that source yet. Can they do dex to damage?
Duelists and Swashbucklers use a different mechanic. You add your class level to damage when using a one handed piercing melee weapon.
I only know of Dervish Dance feat, Sword Lord PrC, and Agile weapon property to add Dex to damage.
Deadly Agility appears to be from the Path of War PFRPG supplement put out by Dreamscarred Press.
|
@OP: You realize that he's sometimes going to use his whip with Truestrike, right? Once he can threaten with the whip at 15' he can cast Truestrike on his turn and expect to use it with an AoO. His first AoO, probably a trip attempt, will be at +20. Trip almost anything.
I'm not saying it's a problem, just mentioning it. Be prepared for him to trip spiders and dragons with 90.25% chance of success. Also, he'll sometimes use Enlarge Person to get a 70' diameter hemispherical zone of control. Be prepared for that.
|
|
The enlarge person thing is kinda scary tripping dragons is kinda cool.
Anyway a guy with a scimitar can do the same thing. Trade out whip feats for trip feats and there you go.
Dang that is a big zone of control. Gonna have to prepare for that. At least there is really no way fit in whirlwind attack.
A fighter with enlarge person, WW attack, greater trip, and combat reflexes. Think I might need an NPC that does that.
I think I just found a new NPC for my campaign too. Except...dual wielding whips?
Hmm even better, how does whirlwind attack interact with dimensional dervish? Whirlwind attack is a full attack, and dervish just let's you teleport during it. Hmmm.
EDIT: answering the actual question.
1. Whip master is a feat for a reason. Don't give him free feats.
2. This has always been my opinion of the scorpion whip, but I know others disagree. They really should errata the specifics of this thing.
3. Should be a thing, isn't a thing. I'd go with the feat blackbloodtroll has posted. Dex to damage isn't worth a mythic feat, and I don't know why it's such a penalized build style.
4. I would say a rod has to be manipulated, and must therefore be in hand to use.
|
The whip master builds for a Kensai are not the most optimal. I find they are great when there is a lot of movement in combat for AoO reasons, but the scimitar deals more damage and it doesn't soak up tons of feats. From a power gamer's perspective, I would use mostly Frostbite, due to the large amounts of attacks I will be making and the debuff potential. That is probably the best route to take to maximize damage.
As a DM, it's really easy to change your encounters slightly to tone down how well your player is fighting. He won't be getting AoO's with a whip until later, and cover will be a pain when he does. Frostbite can be easily toned down by having monsters immune to non-lethal damage. Not being in melee while casting can be countered with ranged attackers, such as an archer readying an action to shoot him if he casts a spell. (His touch AC will be really high, so using ranged touch attacks for this purpose won't be the most effective). Finally, using concealment can force his character to go into melee (such as from obscuring mist).
Though, naturally, you should throw in an encounter or two over the course of this character's life tailored made to allow this character to rock :), every player loves to shine at times.
4. I would say a rod has to be manipulated, and must therefore be in hand to use.
Manipulating an object is a move action though. Certainly you don't require people to use move actions whenever they use a rod... so why force that on a tiefling with a tail?
Meta Rods simply need to be held.