Combat Maneuvers and Swarms


Rules Questions

Grand Lodge

Okay, we all know that creatures with the Swarm Subtype cannot be tripped, grappled, or bull rushed, but what about some other Combat Maneuvers?

1) Can you use the Overrun maneuver on them?

2) Can you use the Reposition maneuver on them?

3) Can you use the Dirty Trick maneuver on them?

4) Can you use the Steal maneuver on them?


Can't see why not ... though 'steal' might be hard, since it's unlikely they'll be holding anything.

Grand Lodge

Zhayne wrote:
Can't see why not ... though 'steal' might be hard, since it's unlikely they'll be holding anything.

Monkeys are known to sometimes have shiny things.


I wasn't aware one could have a swarm of monkeys.

Grand Lodge

Zhayne wrote:
I wasn't aware one could have a swarm of monkeys.

Yes. You can even summon a swarm of them.

Liberty's Edge

2) How does one reposition 300 rats?

3) I can easily imagine using "Dirty Trick" on a rat swarm - kicking dirt into the midst of the swarm could blind enough of them go give the entire swarm the Blind condition.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Theconiel wrote:
2) How does one reposition 300 rats?

Throw cheese.

Liberty's Edge

Zhayne wrote:
Theconiel wrote:
2) How does one reposition 300 rats?
Throw cheese.

lol

Grand Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Zhayne wrote:
Theconiel wrote:
2) How does one reposition 300 rats?
Throw cheese.

Common myth. Peanut Butter is a much bigger attractant to rodents.

Grand Lodge

So, a Barbarian using Overbearing Advance, can deal damage, and leave a Swarm prone?

Lantern Lodge

Pathfinder Adventure, Rulebook Subscriber

I'd say that barbarian could certainly Overrun them (like doing a stompy dance on a swarm of ants), but they'd probably be immune to the prone part of it.

I'll have to make sure to make my players aware of this, as paranoid as they are about my use of swarms.

Shadow Lodge

blackbloodtroll wrote:
Zhayne wrote:
I wasn't aware one could have a swarm of monkeys.
Yes. You can even summon a swarm of them.

According to this you can steal and disarm them. Also, this spell has just become my favorite spell.

Grand Lodge

So, Overrun is the only available Combat Maneuver option?

Liberty's Edge

Stockvillain wrote:

I'd say that barbarian could certainly Overrun them (like doing a stompy dance on a swarm of ants), but they'd probably be immune to the prone part of it.

I'll have to make sure to make my players aware of this, as paranoid as they are about my use of swarms.

The movement portion of Overrun works on any swarm since a swarm does not impede the movement of a creature. Since a swarm cannot be affected by Overrun, it cannot gain the prone condition from the maneuver as well.

As far as the damage from Overbearing Advance, it would not affect a swarm of fine or diminutive creatures since they are immune to weapon damage. Against swarms of larger creatures, the Overbearing Advance would inflict half damage.

As for the other maneuvers:
...Steal: The maneuvers attack may be automatic, but depending on the type of swarm and how they are interacting with the item, the attacker may get part of the swarm with the stolen object.
...Reposition/Drag: I cannot see how you would reposition a mass of small creatures, so no.
...Dirty Trick: This maneuver uses a weak point of a creature to inflict a temporary effect (eyes, knee, etc). I also cannot see a way an entire swarm could be affected by a handful of dirt or hitting a 'sensitive' spot.

The GM is the final arbitrator of what is acceptable and what is not. If it does not make sense, it should not work, regardless of the rule-loopholes a player thinks they have found.

Grand Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Overrun is not a weapon based Combat Maneuver.

Immunity to weapon damage is irrelevant.

Liberty's Edge

Edit: Comment removed

I have no idea why I even bother to try and help you. The arrogancy of many of your comments in this forum is so sad.

Grand Lodge

I think you are reading more into comments, than is there.

Text poorly portrays tone.

Even I have to remind myself of this.


Quote:
A swarm is immune to any spell or effect that targets a specific number of creatures..

Due to the fact that all combat maneuvers affect a target , an opponent, an enemy or a foe i would say that swarms are immune to all combat maneuvers. Same for the prone condition and 'overbearing advance'.

Grand Lodge

Eridan wrote:
Quote:
A swarm is immune to any spell or effect that targets a specific number of creatures..
Due to the fact that all combat maneuvers affect a target , an opponent, an enemy or a foe i would say that swarms are immune to all combat maneuvers. Same for the prone condition and 'overbearing advance'.

Would the same hold true if you have a swarmbane clasp?


kinevon wrote:
Would the same hold true if you have a swarmbane clasp?

Sure or do you see something in the 'Swarmbane clasp' rules that allow combat maneuvers or targeted effects and spells ?

Grand Lodge

Would a Combat Maneuver be considered an "effect that targets a specific number of creatures"?

I mean, not all swarms are immune to weapon damage, but would they still be immune, regardless, due to an attack being considered an "effect that targets a specific number of creatures"?

Dark Archive

I think that's the rub, a Combat Maneuver is (probably) an effect that targets one creature and as thus, the swarm would be immune to it.

Grand Lodge

Well, a Combat Maneuver is an attack.

If immune to all attacks, then it makes sense they would be immune to Combat Maneuvers.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Combat Maneuvers and Swarms All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.