Limited Wish and Foci

[Bollo]

Question: If a Limited Wish is used to reproduce a named spell, and that spell requires a focus, is that focus required.

My first guess is yes, only because as I understand it, a spell's material component requirement and its focus requirement are two different things. And Limited Wish only takes care of the material component part. Right ?

Thanks, and sorry if this subject was brought up in an earlier thread that I was not able to search on.

B.

[LazarX]

It's a GM call. Some GM's might rule you get a temporary focus that' disappears when the spell ends. Others might make it a case by case basis. For example I'm not going to stop you from saving your party with a hasty featherfall gotten this way because your party members aren't carrying feathers on themselves.

[TimrehIX]

I don't think so. You are casting Limited Wish. Even though it duplicates another spell it is not that spell, so the components and casting time come from Limited Wish.

[TimrehIX]

Unless the foci cost more than 1000g then you need it.