Items that break the rules query

[mad_mac_hl]

5 rounds of voting in and enjoying the system so far, well done Paizo. I've come across one thing that concerned me however.

On my 4th pair of items that I was shown to vote on, Item 1 was potentially valid whilst Item 2 was clearly in breach of the rules. I clicked the relevant link to report Item 2 and was then shown two completely new items.

I think it would have been better to have had the 'illegal' item replaced with another voting option as Item 1 looked valid and potentially interesting. The idea that someone loses a potential vote because someone else broke the rules seems a little unfair to me (ok only one vote in the grand scheme of things but still).

So maybe something to consider amending for next years competition?

[Gary Teter]

If you flag one of the items for breaking the rules, we mark the pair as a tie, so it actually doesn't affect the chances for either item at all.

[mad_mac_hl]

Ah, ok no worries. Good to know you've thought of these things :)