PP and money


Pathfinder Society

5/5 * Venture-Lieutenant, Spain—Madrid

Hi everyone!!

Can you spend more than 2 pp to buy an item? I mean, can you purchase a +1 weapon for 6 PP?

Liberty's Edge 4/5 5/5

No, you need to use gold. On the plus side, +1 weapons are on the always available list, so you don't need any particular fame score.

Shadow Lodge 5/5

As an addendum to what Paz just said. You are allowed to spend the maximum of 2 PP once per scenario for one item worth up to 750 gp. You cannot buy multiple combined items up to 750gp, and you may not combine PP to gain a more expensive item.

Grand Lodge 2/5 RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Similarly, you cannot mix PP and gold to pay for something. For example, you can get raise dead cast on your post-Baird body for ~5k gold or 16PP, but you couldn't pay ~2500gp and 8PP for the same effect.

Grand Lodge 4/5

Also remember that you can't just use 2 PP to purchase 750 gp worth of commodities for several scenarios, then sell them for the equivalent gp. As the guide now says, anything purchased using the 1 or 2 PP options have a sales value of 0 gp.

4/5

Jiggy wrote:
Similarly, you cannot mix PP and gold to pay for something. For example, you can get raise dead cast on your post-Baird body for ~5k gold or 16PP, but you couldn't pay ~2500gp and 8PP for the same effect.

This is something I'd like to see changed.

A lot of PP goes unused I think at most a player could generate 22-30,000 gp from spending all of their prestige. This amount should not break the game.

5/5 * Venture-Lieutenant, Spain—Madrid

In that case, there is no reason to buy an item using your faction.
All mundane items are always available, so you can buy them without any worry about fame.
Magic items in chronicles are also always available and you can buy them at any time.
If you can`t acquire an item for 0 gp via PP, why are you going to wait?
Someone can show me an item useful enough to compensate wait for it 10, 15 or 20 modules? I don`t think so.
It has no sense.

Grand Lodge 2/5 RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Miguel Madrid del Ama wrote:

In that case, there is no reason to buy an item using your faction.

All mundane items are always available, so you can buy them without any worry about fame.
Magic items in chronicles are also always available and you can buy them at any time.
If you can`t acquire an item for 0 gp via PP, why are you going to wait?
Someone can show me an item useful enough to compensate wait for it 10, 15 or 20 modules? I don`t think so.
It has no sense.

You can acquire an item for 0gp by spending PP. You can spend 1PP to acquire any one item worth 150gp or less. You can spend 2PP to acquire any one item worth 750gp or less. (It's actually a fairly common practice for a PC's first 2 PP to get them a wand of cure light wounds.)

Liberty's Edge 4/5 5/5 ** Venture-Captain, Texas—Waco

Miguel Madrid del Ama wrote:
In that case, there is no reason to buy an item using your faction.

At higher levels almost all of my purchases are based on my Fame score. Items on chronicle sheets are rarely useful (unless they're partially charged wands or higher CL wands, scrolls, etc), because by that point you almost always have a Fame score high enough to buy the (as an example) +2 Cloak of Resistance anyway. However, how often does a +1 Agile wakizashi appear on a chronicle? And yet my ninja wants one, so he saves up his coppers and golds until his Fame is high enough to convince Grandmaster Torch to help him acquire one.

Grand Lodge 4/5

Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Starfinder Charter Superscriber
Miguel Madrid del Ama wrote:

In that case, there is no reason to buy an item using your faction.

All mundane items are always available, so you can buy them without any worry about fame.
Magic items in chronicles are also always available and you can buy them at any time.
If you can`t acquire an item for 0 gp via PP, why are you going to wait?
Someone can show me an item useful enough to compensate wait for it 10, 15 or 20 modules? I don`t think so.
It has no sense.

Your confusion may be in the GP cap that the Fame level allows you to purchase under. As you earn PP you have the ability to buy any PFS legal item even if it is not on the always available list or on one of your chronicles as long as it is at or below the GP limit set by your Fame. Your faction is the only way to purchase items outside of those on your chronicles or the always available list.

Liberty's Edge 1/5

Ryan Bolduan wrote:
You cannot buy multiple combined items up to 750gp,

But you can buy a scroll with multiple copies of a single spell; you just can't mix and match them. For example, a scroll with five copies of lesser restoration. link

5/5 * Venture-Lieutenant, Spain—Madrid

Ok, you are right. Faction serves to acquire “rare” items, ones that usually don´t appear in chronicles.
But, it sounds odd that Grandmaster Torch is eager to pay 5000 gp material component of a True Restoration Spell but not 2000 gp for a Dagger +1

Grand Lodge 4/5

Miguel Madrid del Ama wrote:

Ok, you are right. Faction serves to acquire “rare” items, ones that usually don´t appear in chronicles.

But, it sounds odd that Grandmaster Torch is eager to pay 5000 gp material component of a True Restoration Spell but not 2000 gp for a Dagger +1

Not quite sure I understand. Diamonds, the material component for both Raise Dead and Restoration of various types, would fall under the Always Available section of the item access, just the same as a Dagger +1 is on the Always Available list.

Or do you mean that in one scenario Grandmaster Torch actually gives the PCs 5,000 gp worth of diamond dust for free?

Shadow Lodge 5/5

Jiggy wrote:
For example, you can get raise dead cast on your post-Baird body for ~5k gold or 16PP

Not sure raise dead is going to help you..

Shadow Lodge 4/5 **** Venture-Captain, Michigan—Mt. Pleasant

I think he means that you can't spend PP to get a +1 Dagger, but you can spend it to get a Raise Dead (5000 gp component and spell cast)

Grand Lodge 4/5

Your faction has a budget, too. Would you prefer they spend it all buying +1 daggers for every new faction member, or save it up for use in serious cases where a raise dead is required?

Grand Lodge 2/5 RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

I've said it before, and I'll say it again: don't try to come up with in-character rationales for how item access works. That way lies madness.

1/5 RPG Superstar 2014 Top 32

Just want to make sure if this is legal:

Can I use my 2pp to buy a Darkwood composite longbow (strength rating +3)
worth 730gp.
and later on pay gold to upgrade it to +1, +2 etc.

that would be using both PP and gold , but the gold would only be spent later on.

edit: and also i assume I would never be able to sell this item, is that correct?

Grand Lodge 2/5 RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Correct on all counts, Grumpus.

The Exchange 5/5

Grumpus wrote:

Just want to make sure if this is legal:

Can I use my 2pp to buy a Darkwood composite longbow (strength rating +3)
worth 730gp.
and later on pay gold to upgrade it to +1, +2 etc.

that would be using both PP and gold , but the gold would only be spent later on.

edit: and also i assume I would never be able to sell this item, is that correct?

First part is correct.

second... not so much. As I understand it, you would have a (+1 magical) Darkwood composite longbow (strength rating +3) that has a value of 2000gp (not 2730gp). and so you COULD sell it... getting 1/2 of the value (that would be 1000gp, NOT 1365gp). At least, that's the way I understand it.

Liberty's Edge 4/5 5/5

I agree with Jiggy; items bought for PP can't be sold at all, even if gold has been spent to magically enhance them.

5/5 *

I'll agree as well. There would be yet another level of recordkeeping to keep track of that we don't need.

The Exchange 5/5

there is no additional value tracking needed. All items are tracked on your Chronicals. Items that you have spent money on can be sold for half thier value - half of what you paid for them. the (+1 magical) Darkwood composite longbow (strength rating +3) in the example above has a value of 2000gp (not 2730gp). 2000gp and 2 PP. if sold, you would recieve half of the gp you spent on the item, or 1000 gp.

edited: IMHO. (figured I'd tag that on as I'm often mistaken)

The Exchange 5/5

CRobledo wrote:
I'll agree as well. There would be yet another level of recordkeeping to keep track of that we don't need.

what additional record keeping? realizing that you have a record of what items you got for free, and what items you have spent money on. You are already saying you need to keep track of which items are paid for with PP...

For example, I have a PC with a wand of CLW with 25 charges, but I decide to sell it. Now... is this a wand I got for free? or one I paid GP for? I need to go check "the records" and see what I paid for it. and if it was fully charged when I paid GP for it, I need to reduce the value of the item by half.

edited: IMHO. (figured I'd tag that on as I'm often mistaken)

5/5 *

Well, I hardly look at my chronicles again after I make my purchases, except to look up boons I might want to use (and I have a separate list to track those... Lots of little ones to miss). Once I purchase an item, and add it to my character it's on my gear. I don't list the value of every item on my sheet, or if I use HeroLab it just assigns it a value (which is again, not transferred to a sheet).

I should have ended my previous post with a YMMV as well. Just saying FOR ME it would be something else to track.

Different topic but, if you bought the bow with PP, then money to upgrade it... why are you selling it down the road? :P

The Exchange 5/5

CRobledo wrote:

Well, I hardly look at my chronicles again after I make my purchases, except to look up boons I might want to use (and I have a separate list to track those... Lots of little ones to miss). Once I purchase an item, and add it to my character it's on my gear. I don't list the value of every item on my sheet, or if I use HeroLab it just assigns it a value (which is again, not transferred to a sheet).

I should have ended my previous post with a YMMV as well. Just saying FOR ME it would be something else to track.

Different topic but, if you bought the bow with PP, then money to upgrade it... why are you selling it down the road? :P

LOL! not sure. at a guess I would say the PC had a strength increase...

perhaps by adding his 4th level and 8th level stat bump to strength. Or even his 4th level. so he needs a Str18 bow now...

back to tracking the item. If you have it noted as "Paid for with PP" or the note "Sale value 0gp" it is already being tracked different. In fact, having paid for the base bow with PP you would have to track it different anyway - HeroLab will give it a value of 730gp (I'm guessing here, as I don't use HeroLab).

5/5 *

LOL, that exact example was my argument that you should be allowed to upgrade the +STR component of composite bows. There is currently no reason for an archer to take STR over DEX bumps. And I wish I had the choice. But we already killed that horse dead once.

Grand Lodge 4/5

nosig wrote:
Grumpus wrote:

Just want to make sure if this is legal:

Can I use my 2pp to buy a Darkwood composite longbow (strength rating +3)
worth 730gp.
and later on pay gold to upgrade it to +1, +2 etc.

that would be using both PP and gold , but the gold would only be spent later on.

edit: and also i assume I would never be able to sell this item, is that correct?

First part is correct.

second... not so much. As I understand it, you would have a (+1 magical) Darkwood composite longbow (strength rating +3) that has a value of 2000gp (not 2730gp). and so you COULD sell it... getting 1/2 of the value (that would be 1000gp, NOT 1365gp). At least, that's the way I understand it.

Nosig, you might want to reread the footnote for the 1 & 2 PP purchases:

Quote:
3 Once per session, you can acquire any single item of this cost or less from your faction by spending the appropriate PP. Items purchased this way are worth 0 gp and cannot be sold.

The bolding is mine, but, unless that changes in a future Guide, you would never be able to sell off that composite longbow or dragonhide breastplate, no matter how much you have enchanted them.

Note: My highest level PC has exactly that longbow that Grumpus was asking about, purchased with 2 PP back in the first module I played him in after converting him from 3.5E to PFRPG, and I have also sunk an additional 8K gp into it, making it +1 & Seeking, but I would think that the "cannot be sold" proviso applies to the item in full, no matter that the 750 gp from the PP is an almost insignificant portion of the "true" value of the item at a later time.

Community / Forums / Organized Play / Pathfinder Society / PP and money All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Pathfinder Society