|
I suggest running a few Pathfinder Society adventures. They are meant for short playing sessions, get you right into the action immediately, and some of them are interconnected for short story arcs.
You might find these to be a better introduction than starting an Adventure Path. I would not run Kingmaker as in my experience running a sandbox is a bit more difficult and requires a bit more preparation than running a more straight forward AP. You also asked for non-3.5. This only leaves Council of Thieves, Serpent Skull, and Carrion Crown as options. I have not played any of these 3, so I can't really comment on how they might run for a new GM.
That being said, I highly recommend you try Runelords as your first AP, even if you have to wait a while. My group was introduced to Pathfinder with Rise of the Runelords, and they loved it. I can think of few better APs to be their 1st, so you might consider waiting for it.
Our group played their first adventure path and first introduction to pathfinder period, with carrion crown. There are some roleplay encounters, but the hard ones come later in the AP. Jade Regent is also pretty easy, i would just leave out the caravan junk.
Listening to "The Chronicler" podcast will be a great help it's on d20radio.com and the first 3 episodes go over crypt of the ever flame for GM's in great detail. Unfortunately I haven't played any APs so I can't help more then the podcast.
In your case, I'd probably just wait for Rise of the Runelords to come out; unless you're playing twice a week or something, it's unlikely that you'll be able to squeeze in another full Adventure Path between now and August anyways.
But if you really can't wait, I'd probably recommend Carrion Crown.
I'd go with any AP that doesn't have an economic sub-game built in.
I have one further question. I don't completely understand the difference between a Pathfinder Society Module and Scenario. It seems as though a Module is a one-and-done adventure for a single level. While a Scenario is more like an Adventure Path. Do I have this right?
The scenarios are all based around the PCs doing errands for the Pathfinder Society and are pretty short; they're designed to fit in one 5 hour session.
The modules aren't necessarily related to the Pathfinder Society and they're longer (maybe 2-3 times as long).
|
Modules are self-contained Adventures that take you through Beginning/Middle/End of a single story. They may be any level, but typically in the low-to-mid range (1-8 or so).
Scenarios are intended for Pathfinder Society (PFS) play, and include Faction Missions and/or may build on future or past scenarios.
In other words, a Module is like a Made for TV Movie, while the PFS Scenarios are like episodes in a recurring series.
At least, as far as I understand them, I may be completely off base.
For your situation, I would recommend a few low-level Scenarios/Modules to get your feet wet and get used to Character Design and the various rules. I know you said you don't want to convert from 3.5ed stuff, but as a new GM, that is some of the best practice for rules mastery you can do.
Rise of the Runelords (anniversary edition or regular one) is a fantastic AP, and really hits on all the main selling points of tabletop RPGs. I think it's worth waiting for, and would have "training runs" until its release in August.
Modules are self-contained Adventures that take you through Beginning/Middle/End of a single story. They may be any level, but typically in the low-to-mid range (1-8 or so).
Scenarios are intended for Pathfinder Society (PFS) play, and include Faction Missions and/or may build on future or past scenarios.
In other words, a Module is like a Made for TV Movie, while the PFS Scenarios are like episodes in a recurring series.
There are some scenarios that build on top of previous ones, but not as many as you might think.
I've been running legacy of fire, and honestly there hasn't been much to convert. Nearly all of the stuff is in the bestiarys, and there is conversions for most of the important NPCs available. Its a lot of dungeon crawl, and very combat oriented (and the lethality can be high which is fun in my experience).
The Beginner Box is very cool, especially if you have no minis or maps already. Grab a dry erease marker and some blank paper and you are off to the races. Consider running the beginner box scenario, then maybe some bashes or little missions you write to get people an idea of how things work. Then roll up new chracters and start Crypt of the Everflame, it is the start of a nice "mini AP" that ties 3 modules together. From Crypt move on to Masks of the Living God, and then on to City of Golden Death.
You will be able to get multiple sessions out of each module, 2 at the least, many more depending on the length of your session and amount of RP.
This little chain will get you up to level 6, close to level 7. By the time you finish you will probably be fast approaching the RotRL release date. Throw in another 7th level module after that and you should be golden.
|
Also check out the Godsmouth Heresy. It's a nice little dungeon crawl.
As for beginner AP's well probably the most straightforward one would probably be Carrion Crown although it does have a distinctive horror theme. Kingmaker and Jade Regent are a bit tough for beginner GM's due to extra systems put in for Kingdom Building and Caravans respectively. Council of Thieves suffers from not really having a distinctive villain and is probably the most combat light of all the AP's. Serpents Skull is let down by the third adventure which is a tad weak.
My advice for you would be to run Crypt of the Everflame and other modules until the Rise of the Runelords comes out. After you get though that Shattered Star may be just what you are looking for.
|
To answer your question as to which Adventure Path is best to run for a first time DM that's Pathfinder: Carrion Crown
It is the most straightforward with the least subsystems and runs in a mostly linear fashion but still has enough non-linear and unique aspects to help grow you as a DM. I would stay away from Kingmaker, Serpent's Skull and Jade Regent. Council of Thieves is a pretty good second choice, but is very roleplay heavy. The second book of that is especially.