Non-magical Weapon Qualities

[Ragnarok Aeon]

I'm wondering if anyone has made any rules involving non-magical weapon qualities. Any links, suggestions, experiences with doing such. I was thinking about qualities ranging from a bonus to hit to extra damage and keen weapons that can be applied to master crafted weapons.

[D'arandriel]

No hard and fast rules, but I allow for exceptional craftsmanship of non-magical weapons to grant bonuses on to hit, damage, initiative, critical threat range, and whatever else I think makes sense. Also, I allow non-magical adamantine weapons to have a non-magical +4 bonus and non-magical mithril weapons to have a +3 bonus (logic being that you need a +4 weapon to bypass DR/adamantine and +3 weapon to bypass DR/silver, which mithril bypasses).

[Aeshuura]

Same here, I leave it up to GM's call, but I try to keep them something that would be explainable as legendary crafstmanship. I have allowed the Dueling property from the APG, but I think that was the only one outside of the ones that D'arandriel mentioned.