Silvanshee Improved Familiar clarification


Rules Questions

Liberty's Edge

In the description for the Silvanshee it is mentioned that a caster with the Improved Familiar feat may have a Silvanshee as a familiar as long as they meet the "proper requirements", but the "proper requirements are never listed. There are other creatures which have a similar statement in Bestiary 2. I am hoping someone from Paizo can specify what these requirements might be.


Nipin wrote:
In the description for the Silvanshee it is mentioned that a caster with the Improved Familiar feat may have a Silvanshee as a familiar as long as they meet the "proper requirements", but the "proper requirements are never listed. There are other creatures which have a similar statement in Bestiary 2. I am hoping someone from Paizo can specify what these requirements might be.

The PFSRD considers it equivalent to level 7, Neutral Good.

Liberty's Edge

Necromancer wrote:
Nipin wrote:
In the description for the Silvanshee it is mentioned that a caster with the Improved Familiar feat may have a Silvanshee as a familiar as long as they meet the "proper requirements", but the "proper requirements are never listed. There are other creatures which have a similar statement in Bestiary 2. I am hoping someone from Paizo can specify what these requirements might be.
The PFSRD considers it equivalent to level 7, Neutral Good.

I would prefer to see the rules laid out by the publisher. It feels like some designer put a #TODO tag on the description and forgot to come back and finish the work. I could compare the power level of the familiar with other familiar options, but rules such as this should be laid out by the designer in my opinion.


Nipin wrote:
Necromancer wrote:
Nipin wrote:
In the description for the Silvanshee it is mentioned that a caster with the Improved Familiar feat may have a Silvanshee as a familiar as long as they meet the "proper requirements", but the "proper requirements are never listed. There are other creatures which have a similar statement in Bestiary 2. I am hoping someone from Paizo can specify what these requirements might be.
The PFSRD considers it equivalent to level 7, Neutral Good.
I would prefer to see the rules laid out by the publisher. It feels like some designer put a #TODO tag on the description and forgot to come back and finish the work. I could compare the power level of the familiar with other familiar options, but rules such as this should be laid out by the designer in my opinion.

Would text from Ultimate Magic help?

Ultimate Magic Appendices


In case someone finds this thread, which seems unanswered... there's this thread: http://paizo.com/forums/dmtz38dd?Bestiary-2-Silvanshee

Short version: It's intended to be a CR 2 on par with the Imp.


I'm not sure how you are seeing this thread as unanswered. Necromancer answered it with a link to the d20pfsrd. When Nipin complained that it wasn't "official", I linked him to the Paizo PRD.

He wasn't asking about the creature's CR, but what level and alignment restrictions are placed on taking it as an improved familiar. Both links provided say "Level 7, Neutral Good".


I have no idea what I was thinking at the time.

Edit: That's the downside to my habit of poking at my characters at 4am.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Silvanshee Improved Familiar clarification All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rules Questions