Spell Strike + Disruptive Spell + Disruptive Recall

[oregwath]

If you use spell strike to deliver a disruptive spell, and the caster fails the concentration check associated with it during his round, would that count for the disruptive recall feat?

Here is my line of thought on this:
Disruptive Spell forces a concentration check to cast spells for one round after being hit by it.
Spell Strike turns a touch spell into a melee attack that can be delivered by a weapon.
Disruptive Recall says that it is triggered when you use a melee attack to disrupt an arcane spellcaster's spell.

It seems to me that this works, but I wanted to make sure by asking what everyone else here thought.

[Bascaria]

What and where is the disruptive recall feat? I can't find it on the SRD. If it's 3rd party, we can only guess at the ruling, but the people here will do their best. Also, if it's 3rd party (and you wouldn't be breaking copyright law by doing so) can you put the text of the feat up here so that we can reference it?

[oregwath]

Bascaria wrote:

What and where is the disruptive recall feat? I can't find it on the SRD. If it's 3rd party, we can only guess at the ruling, but the people here will do their best. Also, if it's 3rd party (and you wouldn't be breaking copyright law by doing so) can you put the text of the feat up here so that we can reference it?

The Disruptive Recall came out in the Ultimate Combat book. I didn't know I was allowed to post the text of the feat, which is why I just did a quick summary of it. Here is the text, and if it turns out that I am not allowed to do this, then I will take it back down.

Prerequisites: Spell recall class feature, Spellcraft 5 ranks.
When you use a melee attack to successfully disrupt an arcane spellcaster's spell, you can immediately use your spell recall class feature to regain a magus spell you have already cast. This ability functions as if you had expended a number of points from your arcane pool equal to the level of the spell you disrupted, up to a maximum level spell you can cast.

[Bascaria]

oregwath wrote:

Bascaria wrote:

What and where is the disruptive recall feat? I can't find it on the SRD. If it's 3rd party, we can only guess at the ruling, but the people here will do their best. Also, if it's 3rd party (and you wouldn't be breaking copyright law by doing so) can you put the text of the feat up here so that we can reference it?

The Disruptive Recall came out in the Ultimate Combat book. I didn't know I was allowed to post the text of the feat, which is why I just did a quick summary of it. Here is the text, and if it turns out that I am not allowed to do this, then I will take it back down.

Prerequisites: Spell recall class feature, Spellcraft 5 ranks.
When you use a melee attack to successfully disrupt an arcane spellcaster's spell, you can immediately use your spell recall class feature to regain a magus spell you have already cast. This ability functions as if you had expended a number of points from your arcane pool equal to the level of the spell you disrupted, up to a maximum level spell you can cast.

My instinct says no. You are using a spell delivered via a melee attack to disrupt the spell casting, but the melee attack itself did not do the work. This seems more applicable to readied action attacks, AoOs, and full-round casting disruptions. I can definitely see the other argument, though, and am more than happy to be proved wrong.