Greater Magic Weapon on bow and arrows - do they stack?


Rules Questions


Title says it all. Would a character gain both the bonuses to attack and damage if they used a bow and arrows that both had Greater Magic Weapon cast on them? ie a +1 GMW bow using +1 GMW Arrow = +2 hit and +2 damage?
Thanks in advance
FDM


No they do not stack, you take which ever magic gives the best bonus, In this case its a waste of a spell to cast it twice.


No.

3.0 worked that way, and it was insane.

Paizo Employee Developer

Greater Magic Weapon gives an enhancement bonus. Enhancement Bonuses do not stack. Therefore a Greater Magic Weapon'd bow and Greater Magic Weapon'd Arrow function the same as if only one of them had the spell cast.

It's the same if you fire a +1 Arrow from a +1 Bow. It's not +2, it still only a +1 bonus because both are enhancement.


I just don't get the point of magic arrows. They are expensive, you could just buy a Bow that is permanent for the same price. So what's the point?

Personally I think anything with ammunition should be 1/2 the price. So +1 bow should be 1000 GP instead of 2000 GP. Only the enhancement bonus applies to the attack roll only. For ammunition again it is 1/2 the price and the enhancement bonus for ammunition is for damage only.

Grand Lodge RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Wouldn't that just add to the complexity? Besides, it can be fun to find a handful of +1 holy arrows on the corpse of the last guy who went to kill the demon you're looking for, you know?

Grand Lodge

Adventure Path Charter Subscriber
voska66 wrote:
I just don't get the point of magic arrows. They are expensive, you could just buy a Bow that is permanent for the same price. So what's the point?

Diversity. You can have some arrows that are flaming, some frosting, some human bane, some dragon bane, some of this type, some of that type and so on. Differing your arrow types puts more tools in your toolbox.

-Skeld

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Greater Magic Weapon on bow and arrows - do they stack? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rules Questions