Mystic Theurge and aligned spells


Rules Questions


Can a mystic theurge cast opposite aligned arcane spells or are those prohibited by the cleric restrictions?


i think he can do it but he'll get in trouble with his deity.

The Exchange Owner - D20 Hobbies

BigNorseWolf wrote:
i think he can do it but he'll get in trouble with his deity.

+1

But this is an "Ask your DM" question.


+1 to the "Ask your DM" part.

As I see it, deities have other things to do than observing each and every follower they get. Especially those who cast spells without using the energy from their deity (read: mystic theurges). As long as the spell isn't used all the time in blatantly obvious ways, the guy should be fine. Now, if the consequences of the spell were against the deity's teachings, now that would attract its attention. For instance, a LG deity might frown a little on one use of an arcane C or E spell, but it will be even more displeased if the spell is used to commit mass murder.

Grand Lodge

I think he can, but only arcane spells using an arcane class spell slot.

He can't cast spells of opposed alignment using his cleric spell slots, even if they're arcane spells.

If he's an arcane preparation-based caster, he can't prepare cleric spells of opposed alignment in his arcane spell slots. He doesn't get access to those cleric spells or options at all. If he's a spontaneous arcane caster, the question becomes easier, because he would have to prepare the spell as a cleric, which he can't do, to cast it spontaneously.


Or chose a True Neutral God of magic, and not worry about it at all.


robert davis 141 wrote:
Can a mystic theurge cast opposite aligned arcane spells or are those prohibited by the cleric restrictions?

No, Robert. You're still operating as a cleric of some sort and until you ditch your deity and get a new one, you're stuck casting the same 'good' spells as everyone else in seminary.


Pathfinder Rulebook Subscriber
robert davis 141 wrote:
Can a mystic theurge cast opposite aligned arcane spells or are those prohibited by the cleric restrictions?

the Wizard hand can cast aligned spells no problem, the Cleric hand may suffer, but that's not the point of the question.

since your Alignment based restriction is for cleric spells, any wizard spell you cast can be any alignment.

your god may frown upon such acts and remove your ability to use divine magic, but again, not part of the question.

short answer: as long as you're not casting divine spells, you're fine.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Mystic Theurge and aligned spells All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rules Questions