A question regarding damage


Rules Questions


You have a strength of 9 and you hit an enemy with a longsword.

Is the damage 1d8 or 1d8-1?

The description of damage under the strength category (pg. 16) is a little confusing.

Scarab Sages

Dorkis wrote:

You have a strength of 9 and you hit an enemy with a longsword.

Is the damage 1d8 or 1d8-1?

The description of damage under the strength category (pg. 16) is a little confusing.

1d8-1, with a minimum of 1 damage.


Karui Kage wrote:
Dorkis wrote:

You have a strength of 9 and you hit an enemy with a longsword.

Is the damage 1d8 or 1d8-1?

The description of damage under the strength category (pg. 16) is a little confusing.

1d8-1, with a minimum of 1 damage.

Actually, in Pathfinder it is a minimum of 1 nonlethal damage. If you were to roll a 1 on 1d8-1 which would normally come out to 0 damage, you deal 1 nonlethal damage.

I think it makes sense, you hit, but not with enough force to deal deadly damage. Longsword for instance might only bruise rather than actually slice skin...


Karui Kage wrote:
Dorkis wrote:

You have a strength of 9 and you hit an enemy with a longsword.

Is the damage 1d8 or 1d8-1?

The description of damage under the strength category (pg. 16) is a little confusing.

1d8-1, with a minimum of 1 damage.

Ok, how about a halfling rogue that has a strength of 5?

Lets say the little guy sneak attacks (3d6) a teenager? Would the damage be 1d3-3 plus 3d6 or 1d3 plus 3d6 minus 3?


Dorkis wrote:
Karui Kage wrote:
Dorkis wrote:

You have a strength of 9 and you hit an enemy with a longsword.

Is the damage 1d8 or 1d8-1?

The description of damage under the strength category (pg. 16) is a little confusing.

1d8-1, with a minimum of 1 damage.

Ok, how about a halfling rogue that has a strength of 5?

Lets say the little guy sneak attacks (3d6) a teenager? Would the damage be 1d3-3 plus 3d6 or 1d3 plus 3d6 minus 3?

What if the same halfling successfully sneak attacked a different teenager but with a +2 dagger? When do you apply the -3 to damage?

Would it be 1d3-3 plus 3d6 plus 2?

Scarab Sages

Sneak attack is just lumped into everything. A halfling rogue with a strength of 5 would do 1d3+3d6-3. With a +2 dagger, this would be 1d3+3d6-1.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / A question regarding damage All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rules Questions