| Patrick Baldwin |
1. No one was sent a cease and desist. We asked those responsible to take it down.
2. The artwork in question contains both copyrighted and trademarked material owned wholly by Paizo and posting it without permission violates both.
3. We're working on a community use policy that will allow our community to do some things--reposting the entirety of our maps online is not one of them.
4. The argument that "you can't stop piracy, so you might as well not try" should be retyped as "you shouldn't try to protect your trademarks so, by law, your trademarks are no longer yours." We're not playing big brother folks, we're protecting our trademarks. No, I'm not saying the map was piracy.
5. Most companies wouldn't take the time to respond--they'd unleash their lawyers on the offender. We have not.
Of course some companies, like White Wolf, would just realize someone
had gone through a ton of work to make a resource players would like,all because they really love the setting.
See the Map of Creation for their Exalted setting at:
http://hd42.de/rpg_exalted_maps.html
Robert Hawkshaw
|
Of course some companies, like White Wolf, would just realize someone
had gone through a ton of work to make a resource players would like,
all because they really love the setting.See the Map of Creation for their Exalted setting at:
http://hd42.de/rpg_exalted_maps.html
You are comparing apples and oranges.
If you go look at the various AP sections of these forums you will see people sharing their hand made maps of dungeons and encounters and paizo giving it the okay.See also the pathfinder wiki.
| eirip |
http://paizo.com/image/content/PathfinderChronicles/GolarionMap.jpg
That should help you for the time being.
Thanks much Robert.
Mark Moreland
Director of Brand Strategy
|
You are comparing apples and oranges.
If you go look at the various AP sections of these forums you will see people sharing their hand made maps of dungeons and encounters and paizo giving it the okay.
See also the pathfinder wiki.
With regards to the Pathfinder Wiki, bear in mind that when we first started the wiki, we contacted several people at Paizo to ask what was acceptable and not and have set strict community guidelines to follow the tenets Paizo set for us. We were granted permission to include any image that appeared on the Paizo Blog, but no other copyright image. Even in these cases, we are providing full disclosure of copyright on all Paizo-owned images and citations throughout the wiki for all Paizo IP (which is, admittedly, most of the wiki's content). Were we to violate the trust between ourselves and Paizo with respect to their intellectual property, trademarks and copyright, I think we'd find ourselves in a similar situation as Urza did with his atlas. We will update our community policies and any other elements of the site to comply with the fan site policy when Paizo releases it.
Robert Hawkshaw
|
Robert Hawkshaw wrote:With regards to the Pathfinder Wiki, bear in mind that when we first started the wiki, we contacted several people at Paizo to ask what was acceptable and not and have set strict community guidelines to follow the tenets Paizo set for us. We were granted permission to include any image that appeared on the Paizo Blog, but no other copyright image. Even in these cases, we are providing full disclosure of copyright on all Paizo-owned images and citations throughout the wiki for all Paizo IP (which is, admittedly, most of the wiki's content). Were we to violate the trust between ourselves and Paizo with respect to their intellectual property, trademarks and copyright, I think we'd find ourselves in a similar situation as Urza did with his atlas. We will update our community policies and any other elements of the site to comply with the fan site policy when Paizo releases it.
You are comparing apples and oranges.
If you go look at the various AP sections of these forums you will see people sharing their hand made maps of dungeons and encounters and paizo giving it the okay.
See also the pathfinder wiki.
hmm I might not have been as clear as I should have been. I was trying to bring up the dungeon maps and the wiki as examples of people working with paizo's permission, making something that fans find very helpful.
I really think that SirUrza's atlas was cool (and looked into doing the same myself thing using some of the googlemaps libraries that have been repurposed for custom maps) but the way he went about it wasn't the best.
SirGeshko
RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32
|
::Casts Resurrection::
I was about to start work on a very similar project, a hyperlinked Atlas for my own use, using various maps as found in the Campaign Setting and other Paizo products.
Alas, all that hard work cannot be shared with the community.
Any word on the "official product that includes similar features" Vic was talking about two years ago??
| Enevhar Aldarion |
::Casts Resurrection::
I was about to start work on a very similar project, a hyperlinked Atlas for my own use, using various maps as found in the Campaign Setting and other Paizo products.
Alas, all that hard work cannot be shared with the community.Any word on the "official product that includes similar features" Vic was talking about two years ago??
This may or may not be what they were talking about back then about making, but it may still do. :)
SirGeshko
RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32
|
This may or may not be what they were talking about back then about making, but it may still do. :)
While that is quite nice, (and I have just the wall to put it on!!) I was thinking more of an interactive map, a simple series of hyperlinked images on the low end of complexity, and something resembling Google Earth on the high end.
Just how far down on the to-do list is it? =P
Take your time. Paizo is quality.
| Justin Franklin |
Enevhar Aldarion wrote:This may or may not be what they were talking about back then about making, but it may still do. :)
While that is quite nice, (and I have just the wall to put it on!!) I was thinking more of an interactive map, a simple series of hyperlinked images on the low end of complexity, and something resembling Google Earth on the high end.
Just how far down on the to-do list is it? =P
Take your time. Paizo is quality.
What if we put the map on each product page with an arrow marking at least where the product starts?
Vic Wertz
Chief Technical Officer
|
Just how far down on the to-do list is it? =P
Take your time. Paizo is quality.
It's hard to say, as it depends on several other things.
One of those things is filling this job opening...