Messing With Madness


Rise of the Runelords


I was just curious if anyone elses PC's started screwing with...
[spoiler] Malfeshnekor

See the moment Malfeshnekor revealed himself the PC's rushed out of the room (they were extraordinarily cautious upon opening the door in the first place) and shut the door. But instead of leaving, they just listened to the barghest pound and scream and such in his maddening desperation. Also the party guessed that he was bound, and was proven such when he eventually broke the door via attacks.

In any case my rogue ended up taunting/mocking/belittling him for a good few rounds, my mind is devoid of some examples at the moment...

But I was wondering if something similar happened to anyone else?

Liberty's Edge

Dran Cronsis wrote:

I was just curious if anyone elses PC's started screwing with...

Spoiler:
Malfeshnekor

See the moment he revealed himself the PC's rushed out of the room (they were extraordinarily cautious upon opening the door in the first place) and shut the door. But instead of leaving, they just listened to the barghest pound and scream and such in his maddening desperation. Also the party guessed that he was bound, and was proven such when he eventually broke the door via attacks.

In any case my rogue ended up taunting/mocking/belittling him for a good few rounds, my mind is devoid of some examples at the moment...

But I was wondering if something similar happened to anyone else?

While not able to comment, I would note that closing your tags is usually a good idea if you're trying to prevent soilers (although I doubt his name is much of a giveaway, to be honest).

So, basically, the rogue mocked him and behaved like a punk? Hmm. I wonder if that might technically count as a Sin...


Kassil wrote:
So, basically, the rogue mocked him and behaved like a punk? Hmm. I wonder if that might technically count as a Sin...

Sloth, maybe, since they were too lazy to kill him :P

*sigh* "Gosh, that seems like a lot of work. Let's just taunt him for a while"

Haven't gotten that far yet. Sorry.


My players haven't gotten there yet, but here's my two coppers:

Spoiler:
I wouldn't have allowed M to bust down the door, I would assume that the binding prevented him from messing with it. It doesn't really matter if the PCs have unlocked it or not, he shouldn't be able to break the door. Otherwise, why didn't he bust it down a long time ago? Or when Nualia showed up? That way he could have been talking to her directly.

Taunting M while the door is closed is petty, and he probably can't hear you that well anyway. Maybe worth a "sin point" for wrath? How about sloth for being too lazy to actually go in and take him out?

Taunting M while the door is open is dangerous. He is free to cast Crushing Despair and Charm Monster on anyone in the next room.

I've seen many posts where one of the PCs got charmed by M and then walked into the room with him, where they were subsequently "pwned".


Giles: "Xander, don't taunt the fear demon."
Xander: "Why? Can he hurt me?"
Giles: "No, it's just...tacky."

...I think that, as in so many ways, Joss Whedon speaks for us all.


Blue_eyed_paladin wrote:

Giles: "Xander, don't taunt the fear demon."

Xander: "Why? Can he hurt me?"
Giles: "No, it's just...tacky."

...I think that, as in so many ways, Joss Whedon speaks for us all.

Buffy Quote FTW!


I wouldn't give a sloth point for taunting; sloth is more a sin of inaction. In this case, they'd be sinful if they knowingly left Mal alone, and considered the matter closed.

I wouldn't call it wrath, either—it isn't violent enough.

I think the best case that could be made is that taunting is a sin of pride. The PC verbally places himself "above" Mal, when he in fact is not. The PC thus has an overly positive self-image that he attained at the expense of another. That's arrogant and overconfident; prideful.


Not attacking Malf at this point would be only prudent , not a sin !

He is binded , the access to him is difficult so there is no urgency to kill him .
On the other hand , the characters are only 3rd level and the chance of death are really important at this point .

If the characters didn't succeed in the plane knowledge skill check , all they know of malf is 'He is the demon Nuala wanted to liberate in order to annihilate Sandpoint'. If they did succeed , they know how powerful he is .

Frankly , I would wait for the characters to finish the skinsaw murders or even hook mountain when they ll have a bit of time . Have the sherif then ask if the adventurers will go back there to deal with the Malf
If they donot ,they are then guilty of SLOTH . If they go, the rogue will be the main target of Malfeshnekor then

The Vorel problem is identical . The characters can not resolve it when they first encounter it . When they'll be 9th level , they will be able to .


Taunting is definitely a Pride thing.

And yes, Malfeshnekor has spells that can affect PCs on the other side of the binding. He can't leave, but his magic can.


Michael F wrote:

My players haven't gotten there yet, but here's my two coppers:

** spoiler omitted **

Spoiler:
Nualia didn't figure out how to get past the pillar of coins, so even if he had broken down the door there wouldnt be direct conversation.

Hmmm? Maybe Nualia has other followers arriving soon from elsewhere? If the pc's have cleared The dungeon, set off any traps and revealed all the secret doors then an unholy contingient of the relevant diety may well get easy access to the room and thus free Malf to wreak revenge, they are good trackers after all!!

Scarab Sages

Kassil wrote:
While not able to comment, I would note that closing your tags is usually a good idea if you're trying to prevent soilers...

Hmmm; if he made them actually soil themselves, I'd say he was pretty damn fearsome!

Is there a sin of filthiness?


Adventure Path Charter Subscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Adventure Path Subscriber

My PCs opened the door and looked in at Malfeshnikor, who promptly charmed the party leader. Even though the rest of the PCs strongly suspected that something was wrong, they didn't want to fight Malfeshnikor, and doubly didn't want to fight him with the party leader under a spell. So Malfeshnikor sent the whole group off looking for a "Greater Sihedron Amulet" to get him out of the imprisoning spell.

I gave the Amulet to Xanesha, and the PCs eventually got hold of it. They then returned to Malfeshnikor. The party leader walked into his room, undid the binding, and said, "You're free to leave--if you can get past me alive." Bloodshed ensued, but the PCs were 7th level by this point, so most of it was Malfeshnikor's blood. (And of course the charm had worn off several days previously.)

Not a very safe response, but it gets points for flair. (Probably the sin of Pride.)

Mary


Taunting could be considered part of pride, yes. Mark him one for pride. It shouldn't affect his alignment or anything.

But Mal sure is attractive, eh? One of my players has his name (well, actually description, since they don't know his name) on his character sheet, in big letters, with a note to go take him down when they're stronger.

They encountered him, one of the fighters was basically beaten within an inch of his life in one round, and they retreated.

Of course, they couldn't just leave the matter alone. Thinking that the door kept him in (they always quickly closed it. They still don't know that he's bound in the room by maagic), they closed the door and left to rest.

They then returned and survived several rounds, each by sheer luck (he was blinked and never hit with all three attacks - sometimes the attack roll was too low, sometimes the miss chance from blink saved them. Had any character been hit by all three attacks, he'd have been dogfood right there.)

So now they are waiting until they're a bit stronger and then will return to thistletop and attack him again. (I'm still contemplating making him stronger when they return, just to mess with them).


Damn, I was sure I closed that tag....That's what I get for staying up for three days.

In any case, Although he probably shouldn't have been able to bust down the door, The Rogue was right on the other side and I kinda wanted it to crush him, he moved beforehand though and M already used his ranged attacks. Also there were ready actions made against the door so it turned into a pretty epic battle. Malfeshnekor touched my Knight players lance and dimension doored deeper into the room. Fortunately for him this forced him to draw a magic weapon so he started doing real damage. Although I thought it a bit off to have M break down his door, I ended up not regretting the decision.

Anyway I've got my different sins assigned and hopefully will be entering the Manor this weekend. That should be entertaining. I'm looking forward to RP'ing his Lordship.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder Adventure Path / Rise of the Runelords / Messing With Madness All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rise of the Runelords