BotBrain
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
That is the question:
Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune,
Or to take arms against a sea of troubles
Ahem…
I figured there should probably be a dedicated thread for this because this is going to be the biggest discussion around the two classes. To get us started, I’d like to give my thoughts, but I am conflicted.
I think Daredevil just about justifies itself in a vacuum. We don’t have a dedicated manoeuvre class. The closest would be swashbuckler, but they’re still only doing them as a means to an end, namely triggering panache. Daredevil wants to trigger adrenaline to do more manoeuvres for the most part and has massive action compression to achieve this. I am also sympathetic to the idea that it would be awesome if this was the sort of things anybody could do. I guess that’s true for every class, but it really stands out here.
Slayer on the other severed monster hand, I just don’t see it. Mark quarry feels like it has very similar problems to investigator where there’s a real chance it just isn’t going to come up, which is the kind of specificity that I really don’t want to see on a class. If this were an archetype feature, this would be more acceptable, as hyper-specific archetypes are common, and people haven’t really had much of an issue with them. It would also let people use the more interesting part of Slayer (Trophies) on any class, which suffers from a similar problem as Daredevil where it really is just something anybody could do.
I doubt Paizo are going to pivot at this stage, and I don’t mean to denigrate the work put into these classes by saying “Ew I don’t want them”, but I think they both need more work to justify them as their own thing. Daredevil might already be there to be honest, but slayer needs more. I think I would lean away from the tracking aspect (especially since it feels very ranger) and more into the trophy-gathering aspect. People bring up Final Fantasy’s blue mages here, and I think that’s a good idea. Battlezoo have already tried something similar, so it could work.
I’m very eager to hear everyone’s thoughts because I’m obviously stuck a bit in the middle of the discussion and I’d like to try and make up my mind.
