| Forgember |
Made a new character the other day, thought I might try my hand at a Ruffian Rogue. Also interested in trying out shield combat a bit and as I made my character I ended up taking Quick Draw thinking it would be nice to get the weapon out a bit quicker. Asked my DM how he felt about me also using it to draw and ready my shield, he paused for a bit as he often does when I ask him anything not strictly RAW and said "sure sounds reasonable".
Figured for the fun of it I would see how you folks stand on the topic. Would you as a DM be cool with Quick Draw working also with drawing and readying a shield?
Thanks much for any input!
| The Gleeful Grognard |
PF1 had quick-draw shields. Shields are (arguably) weapons, so why not?
I wouldn't allow it to draw AND raise a shield in one action.
And since shields have a specific strap (CRB 273 table 6-2)it seems kinda weird mechanically.
Quickdraw works by it being draw and attack in one motion, the shield would be draw, strap, attack.
| Forgember |
Wheldrake wrote:PF1 had quick-draw shields. Shields are (arguably) weapons, so why not?I wouldn't allow it to draw AND raise a shield in one action.
And since shields have a specific strap (CRB 273 table 6-2)it seems kinda weird mechanically.
Quickdraw works by it being draw and attack in one motion, the shield would be draw, strap, attack.
Yep this is why I asked him, glad he was more reasonable. :) Its really only a small difference between the two and it makes quick draw a bit more worth wile.
| theservantsllcleanitup |
Where is the shield being drawn from? Are you talking about like... a shield on your back? A shield on the ground? I'm having trouble understanding where you will be carrying a shield that you could even draw it in the first place.
If it's on your back, I mean, really, one action to take a shield off your back, strap it to your arm, and raise is a bit insane. If it's, idk, attached to your belt? Maybe? Seems extremely unwieldy to me in the first place.
Since you are clearly in houserule territory to begin with, I might suggest making it two actions to take the shield off, strap it on you arm, and raise it for +2 ac. That's still way beyond the quick draw feat's actual purview, but at least it's a bit more reasonable.