| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
I want a hag for a cohort, but there is not one until cohort level 16 (Blood Hag). So what are the other hags?
The Leadership Feat lists a number of cohorts. Monster Cohorts lists some more. The Monstrous Companion Feat lists some as well, but these are duplicates of the previous lists.
What monsters have you made into a cohort, at what level, and can you tell me why that level was chosen?
Existing cohorts by level and name:
Monster|Cohort Level|HD|CR|Role
Haniver gremlin|3|1|0.5|--
Homunculus|3|2|1|No Role
Pseudodragon|3|2|1|Combat Role
Angel, cassisian|4|2|2|Special Role
Archon, harbinger|4|3|2|--
Blink dog|4|3|2|Combat Role
Kami, shikigami|4|3|2|--
Leshy, gourd|4|1|1|--
Pipefox|4|3|2|--
Rakshasa, raktavarna|4|3|2|--
Azer|5|2|2|Any Role
Darkfolk, dark dancer|5|2|1|--
Faun|5|3|1|--
Flumph|5|2|1|--
Ghoul|5|2|1|Combat Role
Hippocampus|5|2|1|Combat Role
Leshy, fungus|5|2|2|--
Worg|5|4|2|Combat Role
Demon, dretch|6|2|2|Combat Role
Festrog|6|2|1|--
Giant eagle|6|4|3|No Role
Hippogriff|6|3|2|No Role
Kech|6|4|3|--
Pegasus|6|4|3|Combat Role
Sasquatch|6|3|2|--
Shadow drake|6|3|2|--
Skeletal champion|6|3|2|--
Contemplative|7|4|2|--
Giant vulture|7|5|4|--
Hell hound|7|4|3|Combat Role
Hound archon|7|6|4|Combat Role
Howler|7|5|3|Combat Role
Jack-o’-lantern|7|2|1|--
Phantom armor, guardian|7|3|2|--
Satyr|7|8|4|Combat Role
Shae|7|4|4|--
Shriezyx|7|7|4|--
Shulsaga|7|4|3|--
Snallygaster|7|4|3|--
Triton|7|3|2|Combat Role
Aranea|8|5|4|Spell Role
Assassin vine|8|4|3|No Role
Draugr|8|3|2|Combat Role
Fossegrim|8|9|4|--
Giant owl|8|6|5|--
Griffon|8|5|4|No Role
Huecuva|8|3|2|--
Pixie|8|4|4|Skill Role
Sea cat|8|6|4|--
Shadow mastiff|8|6|5|--
Shobhad|8|5|4|--
Soulbound doll|8|3|2|Special Role
Tanuki|8|5|4|--
Unicorn|8|4|3|Combat Role
Darkfolk, dark stalker|9|6|4|Combat Role, Skill Role
Ghul|9|6|5|--
Huldra|9|7|4|--
Leucrotta|9|6|5|Special Role
Manticore|9|6|5|Combat Role
Mimic|9|7|4|Combat Role
Phantom armor, giant|9|5|4|--
Sabosan|9|7|5|--
Saguaroi|9|7|5|--
Shredskin|9|4|2|--
Unicorn|9|4|3|Combat Role
Worg, winter wolf|9|6|5|Combat Role
Daemon, vulnadaemon|10|6|4|--
Derhii|10|7|5|--
Divine servitor (Karumzek)|10|5|4|--
Divine servitor (Fantionette)|10|5|4|--
Dragonne|10|9|7|--
Girallon|10|7|6|No Role
Mercane|10|6|5|Combat Role
Oni, kuwa|10|5|4|--
Redcap|10|8|6|Combat Role
Swan Maiden|10|10|6|--
Wyvern|10|7|6|Combat Role
Ahuizotl|11|8|6|--
Babau (demon)|11|9|8|Combat Role, Skill Role
Bralani (azata)|11|7|6|Combat Role
Cloaker|11|6|5|Special Role
Drider|11|9|7|Combat Role, Spell Role
Maftet|11|8|6|--
Nightmare|11|6|5|Combat Role
Owb|11|8|6|--
Soulbound mannequin|11|10|7|--
Sphinx, hieracosphinx|11|8|5|Combat Role
Agathion, vulpinal|12|7|6|Skill Role
Svartalfar|12|13|8|--
Devil, bearded|13|6|5|Combat Role
Hellcat|13|9|7|Combat Role
Kirin|13|9|7|--
Nependis|13|12|9|--
Nephilim|13|11|8|--
Sphinx, criophinx|13|9|6|Combat Role
Vanth (psychopomp)|13|9|7|--
Adlet|14|15|10|--
Axiomite|14|10|8|Combat Role
Daemon, ceustodaemon|14|8|6|Combat Role
Demon, incubus|14|8|6|--
Genie, janni|14|6|4|Combat Role
Giant, wood|14|9|6|Combat Role
Sphinx, gynosphinx|14|12|8|Combat Role
Treant|14|12|8|Combat Role
Archon, legion|15|8|7|--
Avoral|15|9|9|Combat Role
Demon, shadow|15|7|7|Skill Role
Dullahan|15|10|7|Combat Role
Ettin|15|10|6|Combat Role
Invisible stalker|15|7|7|Combat Role, Skill Role
Blood hag|16|12|8|--
Dragon horse|16|10|9|Combat Role
Erinyes (devil)|16|9|8|Combat Role
Garuda|16|11|9|--
Lammasu|16|9|8|--
Naga, guardian|16|12|10|Spell Role
Oni, ogre mage|16|8|8|Combat Role
Sleipnir|16|14|11|--
Sleipnir|16|14|11|--
Angel, movanic deva|17|12|10|Combat Role, Spell Role
Archon, shield|17|9|10|Combat Role
Asura, upasunda|17|12|9|--
Couatl|17|12|10|--
Daemon, piscodaemon|17|11|10|--
Einherji|17|13|10|--
Leonal|17|14|12|Combat Role
Shedu|17|11|9|--
Valkyrie|17|16|12|--
Viper vine|17|20|13|No Role
Xanthos|17|17|14|--
Stone giant|18|12|8|Combat Role
Haniver gremlin|3|1|0.5|--
Homunculus|3|2|1|No Role
Pseudodragon|3|2|1|Combat Role
Angel, cassisian|4|2|2|Special Role
Archon, harbinger|4|3|2|--
Blink dog|4|3|2|Combat Role
Kami, shikigami|4|3|2|--
Leshy, gourd|4|1|1|--
Pipefox|4|3|2|--
Rakshasa, raktavarna|4|3|2|--
Azer|5|2|2|Any Role
Darkfolk, dark dancer|5|2|1|--
Faun|5|3|1|--
Flumph|5|2|1|--
Ghoul|5|2|1|Combat Role
Hippocampus|5|2|1|Combat Role
Leshy, fungus|5|2|2|--
Worg|5|4|2|Combat Role
Demon, dretch|6|2|2|Combat Role
Festrog|6|2|1|--
Giant eagle|6|4|3|No Role
Hippogriff|6|3|2|No Role
Kech|6|4|3|--
Pegasus|6|4|3|Combat Role
Sasquatch|6|3|2|--
Shadow drake|6|3|2|--
Skeletal champion|6|3|2|--
Contemplative|7|4|2|--
Giant vulture|7|5|4|--
Hell hound|7|4|3|Combat Role
Hound archon|7|6|4|Combat Role
Howler|7|5|3|Combat Role
Jack-o’-lantern|7|2|1|--
Phantom armor, guardian|7|3|2|--
Satyr|7|8|4|Combat Role
Shae|7|4|4|--
Shriezyx|7|7|4|--
Shulsaga|7|4|3|--
Snallygaster|7|4|3|--
Triton|7|3|2|Combat Role
Aranea|8|5|4|Spell Role
Assassin vine|8|4|3|No Role
Draugr|8|3|2|Combat Role
Fossegrim|8|9|4|--
Giant owl|8|6|5|--
Griffon|8|5|4|No Role
Huecuva|8|3|2|--
Pixie|8|4|4|Skill Role
Sea cat|8|6|4|--
Shadow mastiff|8|6|5|--
Shobhad|8|5|4|--
Soulbound doll|8|3|2|Special Role
Tanuki|8|5|4|--
Unicorn|8|4|3|Combat Role
Darkfolk, dark stalker|9|6|4|Combat Role, Skill Role
Ghul|9|6|5|--
Huldra|9|7|4|--
Leucrotta|9|6|5|Special Role
Manticore|9|6|5|Combat Role
Mimic|9|7|4|Combat Role
Phantom armor, giant|9|5|4|--
Sabosan|9|7|5|--
Saguaroi|9|7|5|--
Shredskin|9|4|2|--
Unicorn|9|4|3|Combat Role
Worg, winter wolf|9|6|5|Combat Role
Daemon, vulnadaemon|10|6|4|--
Derhii|10|7|5|--
Divine servitor (Karumzek)|10|5|4|--
Divine servitor (Fantionette)|10|5|4|--
Dragonne|10|9|7|--
Girallon|10|7|6|No Role
Mercane|10|6|5|Combat Role
Oni, kuwa|10|5|4|--
Redcap|10|8|6|Combat Role
Swan Maiden|10|10|6|--
Wyvern|10|7|6|Combat Role
Ahuizotl|11|8|6|--
Babau (demon)|11|9|8|Combat Role, Skill Role
Bralani (azata)|11|7|6|Combat Role
Cloaker|11|6|5|Special Role
Drider|11|9|7|Combat Role, Spell Role
Maftet|11|8|6|--
Nightmare|11|6|5|Combat Role
Owb|11|8|6|--
Soulbound mannequin|11|10|7|--
Sphinx, hieracosphinx|11|8|5|Combat Role
Agathion, vulpinal|12|7|6|Skill Role
Svartalfar|12|13|8|--
Devil, bearded|13|6|5|Combat Role
Hellcat|13|9|7|Combat Role
Kirin|13|9|7|--
Nependis|13|12|9|--
Nephilim|13|11|8|--
Sphinx, criophinx|13|9|6|Combat Role
Vanth (psychopomp)|13|9|7|--
Adlet|14|15|10|--
Axiomite|14|10|8|Combat Role
Daemon, ceustodaemon|14|8|6|Combat Role
Demon, incubus|14|8|6|--
Genie, janni|14|6|4|Combat Role
Giant, wood|14|9|6|Combat Role
Sphinx, gynosphinx|14|12|8|Combat Role
Treant|14|12|8|Combat Role
Archon, legion|15|8|7|--
Avoral|15|9|9|Combat Role
Demon, shadow|15|7|7|Skill Role
Dullahan|15|10|7|Combat Role
Ettin|15|10|6|Combat Role
Invisible stalker|15|7|7|Combat Role, Skill Role
Blood hag|16|12|8|--
Dragon horse|16|10|9|Combat Role
Erinyes (devil)|16|9|8|Combat Role
Garuda|16|11|9|--
Lammasu|16|9|8|--
Naga, guardian|16|12|10|Spell Role
Oni, ogre mage|16|8|8|Combat Role
Sleipnir|16|14|11|--
Sleipnir|16|14|11|--
Angel, movanic deva|17|12|10|Combat Role, Spell Role
Archon, shield|17|9|10|Combat Role
Asura, upasunda|17|12|9|--
Couatl|17|12|10|--
Daemon, piscodaemon|17|11|10|--
Einherji|17|13|10|--
Leonal|17|14|12|Combat Role
Shedu|17|11|9|--
Valkyrie|17|16|12|--
Viper vine|17|20|13|No Role
Xanthos|17|17|14|--
Stone giant|18|12|8|Combat Role
Looking these up by their Monsters by Role, I get the following averages:
Cohorts by monstrous role:
Monster Role|CL-HD|CL/HD|CL/CR
--|2.90|1.65|2.43
Combat Role|3.89|1.66|2.29
No Role|1.86|1.55|2.23
Skill Role|5.00|1.79|1.99
Special Role|3.75|2.00|2.50
Spell Role|4.00|1.45|1.77
--|2.90|1.65|2.43
Combat Role|3.89|1.66|2.29
No Role|1.86|1.55|2.23
Skill Role|5.00|1.79|1.99
Special Role|3.75|2.00|2.50
Spell Role|4.00|1.45|1.77
Assigning roles where needed, and based off these numbers I get:
Annis Hag|12|7|6|Combat Role*
Green Hag|13|9|5|Combat Role
Mute hag|19|14|11|Spell Role*
Night Hag|13|8|9|Combat Role
Sea Hag|8|4|4|Combat Role
Storm Hag|16|10|7|Combat Role*
Winter Hag|17|10|7|Special Role*
* = best guess
Any thoughts?
/cevah