Replacement for Carrion Crawler


Homebrew and House Rules


What is the best replacement made by Paizo for the Carrion Crawler?


What sort of similarities are you looking for? Same CR? Same abilities? Same flavor? Other similarities?


Pathfinder Maps Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber

How about the slime crawler?

Or just use the D&D 3.5 stats.

RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32

2 people marked this as a favorite.

Unless you are doing this for publication, a Carrion Crawler is the best replacement for a Carrion Crawler.

Scarab Sages

The slime crawler is an obviously intentional substitute/reskinning of the carrion crawler. And, imo, the three stage family of creatures culminating in the carrion moth, is an improvement on the original single stage carrion crawler. Originally, the Tome of Horrors only presented stage one and three, with the carrion crawler being the understood second stage, and I am happy to see them inserting a new second stage in the life-cycle to replace the out-of-bounds carrion crawler.

The only thing re the original question, is that its not from Paizo; but Paizo uses the Tome of Horrors often enough itself that it really should not matter.


There are some bootleg versions of the monsters that WotC didn't allow to cross over floating around the internet. Or so I've heard. *whistles nonchalantly*


Wheldrake wrote:

How about the slime crawler?

Or just use the D&D 3.5 stats.

What is the legal status of the "Tome of Horrors" monsters? Can one write the stats in full so readers don't have to refer to the book or go to a webpage? It appears to be $109 for a hardcopy and $29 for a PDF. That's pretty steep.

Some people don't have access to D&D 3.5 books and the Carrion Crawler is not in the SRD.


I just sent you an email here on the boards.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

There's a reason I still have a copies of a bunch of WOTC 3.5 monster books on my shelf...

Honestly, for any 3.5 monster that you want to use, just compare the 3.5 numbers with the Monster Statistics by CR table and adjust upward as necessary. As presented, 3.5 monsters are usually a CR or two behind what their stats would indicate in PFRPG.

I use carrion crawlers in my games not infrequently... ditto umber hulks.

Scarab Sages

darth_borehd wrote:
Wheldrake wrote:

How about the slime crawler?

Or just use the D&D 3.5 stats.

What is the legal status of the "Tome of Horrors" monsters? Can one write the stats in full so readers don't have to refer to the book or go to a webpage? It appears to be $109 for a hardcopy and $29 for a PDF. That's pretty steep.

Some people don't have access to D&D 3.5 books and the Carrion Crawler is not in the SRD.

All creatures found in the Tome of Horrors are OGL and can be used in other publications so long as you properly reference the Tome of Horrors in your own section 15 of the OGL.

You can write the stats in full.


Wicht wrote:
darth_borehd wrote:
Wheldrake wrote:

How about the slime crawler?

Or just use the D&D 3.5 stats.

What is the legal status of the "Tome of Horrors" monsters? Can one write the stats in full so readers don't have to refer to the book or go to a webpage? It appears to be $109 for a hardcopy and $29 for a PDF. That's pretty steep.

Some people don't have access to D&D 3.5 books and the Carrion Crawler is not in the SRD.

All creatures found in the Tome of Horrors are OGL and can be used in other publications so long as you properly reference the Tome of Horrors in your own section 15 of the OGL.

You can write the stats in full.

W00t! I'm not publishing it for profit but will be posting an adventure for free online.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Homebrew and House Rules / Replacement for Carrion Crawler All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Homebrew and House Rules