so FAQ says silence effects a witch , the witch can't cackle in silence.
and the subject must be able to hear the Cackle. subject can't be in silence.
what about when the subject is effected by the Scar Hex?
they normally get extended with Cackle via Scar. So does it matter if the subject, who can be a mile away, can hear the witch or not? Can a Scar Cackle break through Silence and effect a target as long as the witch is not in Silence?