
Dekalinder |
2 people marked this as FAQ candidate. |

Two simple question that comed up in my mind and i can't find any responses anywhere
1) Does Aura of Cowardice affects mindless creatures or creatures otherwise immune to mind affacting spells like undead or vermins?
2) Is Cruelty considered a fear effect whe used to convoy the shackened/frightned affliction?

Shadowborn |

1) No. Zombies, giant ants, and black puddings, and animated statues aren't immune to fear because they have a magical ability that the antipaladin's aura can override. They're immune to fear because they don't have an Intelligence score, which the antipaladin's aura doesn't grant them.
2) Yes, Cruelty is a supernatural effect; the shaken or frightened effects would be supernatural fear effects.

Chengar Qordath |

1) No. Zombies, giant ants, and black puddings, and animated statues aren't immune to fear because they have a magical ability that the antipaladin's aura can override. They're immune to fear because they don't have an Intelligence score, which the antipaladin's aura doesn't grant them.
But Aura of Cowardice doesn't say anything about only negating magical immunity to fear, and no other form. By RAW, no form of immunity to fear works against an anti-paladin.

packerfanjeff |
It's a question of what trumps what. Can God make a Rock so big that he can't move it? Paladin is immune. PERIOD. Anti-Paladin negates immunities. PERIOD.
The Paladin immunity does not say it works against everything but Anti-paladins.
I would argue that RAW is inconclusive at best.
Probably a fairer thing to do would be to say that the higher level char (which is usually the bad guy in most campaigns) would have the "slightly" stronger aura and would win.
waiting to see a FAQ on this one. To say that Anti-Paladin always trumps Paladin seems overly tilted towards that spectrum of equal (and opposite, diametrically opposed) chars.