Anyone willing to take a look at a new cleric guide and give it a read-through? I'd like a few people to look at it before submitting it here.
Eh, why not. PM me a link.
Eh, why not. PM me a link.Same here. I might have some time available this week-end
PS : how will you want the feedback ? On this thread (which could get people interested in your guide even before they can read it) or through PMs (if you prefer some confidentiality)
Key me in if you want.
Eh, why not. PM me a link.Same here. I might have some time available this week-end
PS : how will you want the feedback ? On this thread (which could get people interested in your guide even before they can read it) or through PMs (if you prefer some confidentiality)
Thanks for helping out :-)
On here works. While I'm not new to writing, I'm definitely new with writing a guide to Pathfinder - so I want to make the general concept/direction/tone of the thing is worth trying to put among the guides. Last thing I want is to burst into the 'Guide to the Guides' thread, say, "Look at this cool new guide!", and have the general consensus be, "Uh, dude, that character concept sucks"
|
First, I will start by apologizing for not being able to spend much time on this guide. RL struck hard this week-end and blew my plans to smithereens.
Still, I think you should put the link up for all to comment on this guide.
Having read a little of it (intro and conclusion really), I am not sure that this build you're selling here is as good as you think it is.
However, YOU believe in it, to the point of writing a whole guide about it. And the quality of the guide (ie, easy to read and to understand) was enough for me to actually get interested in it, so no problem here I think ;-)
I like all the effort you put into this (for example the mini-guide to Sacred Summons) and I think you should get a reward for it.
Also, who knows how many eye-opening posts this guide will inspire and how many players will actually try and build such a character.
Go for it. Not everyone will agree with your theory, but being criticised is way better than staying in the shadows.
First, I will start by apologizing for not being able to spend much time on this guide. RL struck hard this week-end and blew my plans to smithereens.
Still, I think you should put the link up for all to comment on this guide.
Having read a little of it (intro and conclusion really), I am not sure that this build you're selling here is as good as you think it is.
However, YOU believe in it, to the point of writing a whole guide about it. And the quality of the guide (ie, easy to read and to understand) was enough for me to actually get interested in it, so no problem here I think ;-)
I like all the effort you put into this (for example the mini-guide to Sacred Summons) and I think you should get a reward for it.
Also, who knows how many eye-opening posts this guide will inspire and how many players will actually try and build such a character.
Go for it. Not everyone will agree with your theory, but being criticised is way better than staying in the shadows.
I'm still reading through it. I put myself in the position of a player you're trying to cater to. Honestly, You may consider other reach weapons as well, like a scorpion whip or something. My final review will be up in a few days.
Wanted to thank everyone that's helped out so far, and I've done a number of revisions/rewriting. The biggest one was Tark's take that, if I'm doing a focused guide specifically for one type of build, I don't want to try to be comprehensive on every possible option - just the good ones.
How do I go about things from here? Do I just start a new thread? Do I post in the stickied "Guide to the Guides" thread?
