Unarmed Attack + Natural Attacks


Rules Questions


Notice: I am NOT talking about flurry, so no need to point out you can't flurry with natural attacks. Thanks!

So, say you are an Orc Ranger with the natural weapon style. You have 2 claws and a bite as natural attacks.

You then take improved unarmed strike and two weapon fighting.

So you could, say, kick someone at full BaB -2 and make 2 claws and a bite as secondary attacks, (-5 to attack and 1/2 str to damage)

The book says that you treat your secondary natural attacks as 2 weapon fighting, so you need the Two Weapon Fighting feat to avoid massive penalties.

Or would it be 2 kicks at full BaB -2, and 2 claws and a bite as secondary attacks?

What do you think?

Dark Archive

The book is wrong about treating secondary attacks as two-weapon fighting. That was changed awhile ago I think.

But yes, with TWF, two kicks/knees, etc. at BAB -2, and three secondary attacks. Add your favoured enemy to all of them.

Grand Lodge

Natural attacks do not interact, or use the two weapon fighting rules in any way. You suffer the same penalties to natural attacks whether you attack with one manufactured weapon(or unarmed strike), or two.
You must be using a older print of the core rulebook.
Look to the Bestiary for the legit use of natural attacks used with weapon attacks.


Mergy wrote:

The book is wrong about treating secondary attacks as two-weapon fighting. That was changed awhile ago I think.

But yes, with TWF, two kicks/knees, etc. at BAB -2, and three secondary attacks. Add your favoured enemy to all of them.

Yeah, on further reflection that makes sense. I was actually thinking of going Ninja for the rest of the character career. Sneak attack plus many attacks could be awesome.

So, Ranger 2/ Ninja 6 would have a BaB of +6. With two weapon fighting and improved two weapon fighting, you would have....

2 kicks at +4, 2 kicks at -1, and 2 claws and a bite at +1? plus str mod, possibly favored enemy, and 3d6 sneak attack

I was thinking that 7 attacks would make Amulet of Mighty Fists worth it

Dark Archive

You are correct, although only as a full-round action.

Also, be very quick about rolling and calculating your attacks; your turn will take awhile even if you are fast. If you're slow to roll or calculate bonuses, this may not be the character for you.


Hmm... now the Double Slice feat lets you use your full strength mod on 'off hand attacks'

Would that apply to the secondary natural attacks as well?

Grand Lodge

Double slice does not apply to natural attacks.
You should look into the Feral Combat Training feat.
Also, if you want to be sneaky, and multiclass, go into Inquisitor, as the synergy is much better.
Going into ninja will make you weak.


blackbloodtroll wrote:

Double slice does not apply to natural attacks.

You should look into the Feral Combat Training feat.

Arg! You always recommend Feral Combat Training!

Prerequisite: Improved Unarmed Strike, Weapon Focus with selected natural weapon.

Benefit: Choose one of your natural weapons. While using the selected natural weapon, you can apply the effects of feats that have Improved Unarmed Strike as a prerequisite, as well as effects that augment an unarmed strike.

Special: If you are a monk, you can use the selected natural weapon with your flurry of blows class feature.

Am I missing something here? This is not a monk, there is no stunning fist.

Grand Lodge

Dragon Style, Weapon of Awe spell, and many other examples make this feat a boon for non-monk PCs. In fact, if you take Dragon Style, then a single level dip into Unarmed fighter to gain Dragon Ferocity, you will get x2 strength on the first attack made with the chosen natural weapon.

It is just too good for this build.


blackbloodtroll wrote:

Dragon Style, Weapon of Awe spell, and many other examples make this feat a boon for non-monk PCs. In fact, if you take Dragon Style, then a single level dip into Unarmed fighter to gain Dragon Ferocity, you will get x2 strength on the first attack made with the chosen natural weapon.

It is just too good for this build.

I don't know if taking weapon focus and Feral Combat training are worth it just to improve 2 of the 7 attacks in this build.

Grand Lodge

Those said feats will still effect your unarmed strikes as well.
Double Slice will effect unarmed strikes, combine them all, and this will mean:
Unarmed strike 1 = x2 str
Unarmed strike 2 = x1.5 str
Claw 1 = x2 str
Claw 2 = x1 str
Bite = x.5 str


Yeah, Dragon Style might be worth it.
Not weapon focus (claw) and Feral Combat Training (claw)

Grand Lodge

Well, until higher levels, using a full attack to attack with natural attacks is a better option. Also, dragon style combined with feral combat training will give you a -1 to +3 ratio for power attack on your claw.


Dragon style only gives the 1 and 1/2 bonus on the first unarmed strike, that is the only one that would gain the -1 to +3 for power attack.

Also, the claws and bite are secondary if you use other attacks, so would not benefit as power attack specifies a primary natural attack gets the better ratio.

The second dragon feat gives a bonus on damage equal to half your str bonus, which is not the same thing.

I don't plan on power attack anyway, not without a full BaB. That is why I was thinking sneak attack.

Still, the unarmed fighter with dragon style isn't a bad option.

Also, I am making a kitsune character for society, so I might do this as a finesse build. Haven't decided

Grand Lodge

Hmm, for a finesse build, AoMF with the Agile property is a must. A one or two level dip into Urban Barbarian to pump dex. There is a feat line for Kitsune to nab pounce that would synergize well.


Yeah, this is gonna be a society character though. Never gonna get the base attack up high enough

Grand Lodge

Vulpine Pounce requires +10 BAB, and PFS caps out at 12th.


And I said I planned to go Ninja.

Grand Lodge

Ah, I was mistaken. I did not know Ninja was set in stone.


Meh, well now that I know there are going to be options for the Kitsune in Advanced Races, nothing is going to be final until I read it

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Unarmed Attack + Natural Attacks All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.