Shatter to sunder?


Rules Questions


need I ask more?

Dark Archive

Perhaps a stated question, not an implied one, would help.


Carbon D. Metric wrote:
Perhaps a stated question, not an implied one, would help.

I know :(

anyways...

Can you break a weapon with this?

The only part that requires inattention is the first use.

Dark Archive

You can use it to sunder a non-magical weapon yes. If the item is magical though it's tough luck.


Carbon D. Metric wrote:
You can use it to sunder a non-magical weapon yes. If the item is magical though it's tough luck.

Objects use the wielder's will?


Dispel/shatter


Sandbox wrote:
Dispel/shatter

An object under a successful dispel attempt is still magical, just with magic suppressed. Not sure this works.


Sloppycrane wrote:
Carbon D. Metric wrote:
You can use it to sunder a non-magical weapon yes. If the item is magical though it's tough luck.
Objects use the wielder's will?

You need to read the spell description not just the tidbits at the top, it states only non magical items or crystaline creatures. Also as stated dispel just keeps a objects wielder from accessing the magical aspects once successfully dispelled, it is still a magical item and so the spell wouldn't work on it per the description. The only cases I can think of that line of reasoning working is if an item were "magical" due to a permanent ongoing spell effect (Not a crafted permanent item, the two are different) so it becomes a non magical item after dispel or charged item that was somehow drained of charges so it becomes non magical (ie a wand).


Sloppycrane wrote:
need I ask more?

Yes, you need to ask more.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Shatter to sunder? All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.