More Fuel for Roleplaying hate...


Gamer Life General Discussion

Silver Crusade

Stupidity.

Article


The very idea of a "D&D gang" should be enough to inspire laughter, not fear.

Unbelievable!


one of my old player learned to play in prison, he played with all the lifers, no one messed with the lifers but it was not because of D&D


I don´t think it fosters roleplaying hate in general, but I sure do think that this decision is a load of BS. With that reasoning, anything inside a prison can be banned, because you never know what it might bring one day. Clothes? Well, an inmate might fashion a club of sorts from a sleeve and some plaster scraped from the walls, so ban clothes. Sure, it could in theory happen, but what are the chances? This is indeed ridiculous.

Stefan


We had a guy play briefly in our group that was recently released from prison. He played in prison and the prisoners weren't allowed to have regular dice. So they made dice out of paper and weighted them with salt. They could only make 6 sided die so some conversion to the rules happened. He said that it was fun and the GM was very imaginative with the games.

A little ray of happieness in an otherwise dreary existance I guess.


D&D gang :) guess that majes you the biggest gang in the world. So when do we start the inter-gang wars with the 4e pretenders then.

Sorry couldnt help myself.

Sovereign Court RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8

Yeah that's stupid. They have *actual* gang issues they can't stop, so they go after the only thing that teaches socialization.


Uhmm, with that reasoning they could also ban any kind of written material, stupid. But they can play Shadowrun, playing games about sci-fi outcasts that kill cops and punks alike :D

I would like to know what the D&D Godfather says about the issue.


The smitter wrote:
one of my old player learned to play in prison, he played with all the lifers, no one messed with the lifers but it was not because of D&D

I've got to admit, I'm curious as to what an rpg session would be like amongst a bunch of lifers. That's a fascinating concept.


Immortalis wrote:

D&D gang :) guess that majes you the biggest gang in the world. So when do we start the inter-gang wars with the 4e pretenders then.

Sorry couldnt help myself.

Apparently you missed out on the 4vengers from the WotC boards 2 years ago... But it's okay, you didn't miss much.


No havent been on the WotC site since 4e got started.


Immortalis wrote:
No havent been on the WotC site since 4e got started.

Aww, you missed all the fun. A bunch of forum regulars banded together calling themselves the 4vengers, and would gang up on and harass anyone who dared had the slightest negative opinion of 4e. The beauty part was, since they were "supporting"(and that's an understatement) WotC's new product, they rarely, if ever, got moderated. They were free to harass and insult to their hearts content.

Not exactly comparable to a prison gang, but still pretty irritating.

Scarab Sages

I have to wonder what kind of person they got to defend D&D against this silly argument, and what kind of effort the person put into it. I'm guessing it couldn't have been much.

Also, I didn't notice if they just singled out D&D, or was it a ban on all RPGs?

Either way, I'd bet there are waaaayyyy more important things they could have spent time and money on.

Scarab Sages

Noticed the following among the article comments and thought it was a very good point.

"If you follow this kind of thinking then you have to come to the fact that religion promotes "gang-like" activity where members are encouraged to look to their leader above and beyond any other authority. Some religions pass out pamphlets and try to recruit at the drop of a hat. I don't think they'll be taking away Bibles etc."


If the link is right, the court didn't have to prove that D&D is dangerous for some reason, instead it was the player who had to prove that D&D would be ok under any remotely possible scenario.
It was a façade imo, they saw the convicted having too much fun and they decided to ruin it.


I liked reading the comments that Fox News readers left under their article on it. A lot of them were along the lines of "Why are prisoners allowed to play GAMES? Aren't we supposed to be PUNISHING them as harshly as possible for all eternity? They should be locked in a 2 x 2 pit of chest-deep water infested with rats, hanging by their wrists!" Well, OK, so I made up the last example, but the tenor is there.

It was refreshing to read some of the replies, along the lines of, "Wow, dude, that's sure to make them into well-adjusted citizens (NOT!)."

Lantern Lodge

I am 23 years old and upon reading this article I had no other choice than to LOL. Only something like this could happen in my wife's home state. Thanks to this article, I have now officially for the first time in my life (that I recall) used LOL as a verb in a sentence.

Thank you, Wisconsin Legislature, you cursed rats!


Wow. Just....wow.

Community / Forums / Gamer Life / General Discussion / More Fuel for Roleplaying hate... All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in General Discussion