Hi everyone,
I am DM for two ROTRL Groups with 5 Players each. Finally both groups are done with HMM (one is already done with FotSG). I made a survey about each adventure in the path to give Paizo a bit of feedback.
Keep in mind, that as DM I may have changened small pieces and added or lost some NPC's or Fights (some things came from these boards)
Under the Spoiler buttons are, well, spoliers. Players beware
The Award Catagories are:
Best Location
most memorable Villain
Best Battle or Scene
PART 1 BURNT OFFERINGS
Best Location:
The Town of Sandpoint
Sandpoint Glasworks
The Catacombs of Wrath
The Thistle Tunnels
Thistletop
Most memorable Villain:
The Goblins (we be Goblins – you be food)
Tsuto Kaijitsu (male half-elf rogue)
Erylium (quasit thaumaturge)
Gogmurt (male goblin druid)
Warchief Ripnugget (male goblin fighter)
Nualia (female aasimar fighter)
Malfeshnekor (advanced elite greater barghest)
Best Battle or Szene:
The Swallowtail Festival
The Goblins attack
The goblin in the closet
The battle at the glasworks
Fighting the Sinspawns in the catacombs
Fight with Erylium at the runewell
Fight with Gogmurt in the thistle tunnels
Fight with Warchief Ripnugget on Stickfoot and his Minions
Interactions with the captuered warhorse and Orik Vancaskerkin
Fight with Nualia (including trap)
Fight with Malfeshnekor
Best Location:
1. Thistletop 5 Votes
2. The Town of Sandpoint 3 Votes
3. The Catacombs of Wrath 1 Vote
Most memorable Villain:
1. Warchief Ripnugget 5
2. The Goblins 2
3. Nualia 1
Best Battle or Szene:
1. Fight with Warchief Ripnugget on Stickfoot and his Minions 3
2. Fight with Nualia (including trap) 3
3. The Goblins attack 2
PART 2 THE SKINSAW MURDERS
Best Location:
Sandpoint
The Hambley Farm
Foxglove Manor
Magnimar
The Copper Dwarf
Foxglove Townhouse
The Skinsaw Sawmill
The Shadow Clock
Most memorable Villain:
Foxglove Manor (the haunts)
Aldren Foxglove (male dread ghast aristocrat/rogue)
The faceless stalkers (shapshifters)
Justice Ironbriar (male halfelf cleric)
The scarecrow (lifespark flesh golem)
Xanesha (lamia matriarch sorcerer)
Best Battle or Szene:
Murder at the Sandpoint lumber mill
investigations in Sandpoint
Battle with ghouls at the Hambley Farm
The Haunts at Foxglove Manor
Fight with Aldren in the caverns
Spending quality time at the Copper Dwarf
Battle with the faceless stalkers
Battle with the cultists and Justice Ironbriar at the sawmill
Fight with the Scarecrow
Fight with Xanesha at the Clocktower
Best Location:
1. Foxglove Manor 6
2. The Hambley Farm 2
3. Magnimar 1
3. The Copper Dwarf 1
Most memorable Villain:
1. Foxglove Manor 6
2. Xanesha 2
2. The scarecrow 2
Best Battle or Szene:
1. The Haunts at Foxglove Manor 3
2. Fight with Xanesha at the Clocktower 3
3. Spending quality time at the Copper Dwarf 2
PART 3 THE HOOK MOUNTAIN MASSACRE
Best Location:
The Graul Farm
Fort Rannick
Skull's Crossing
Hook Mountain Clanhold
Most memorable Villain:
Mammy Graul (Female Ogre-kin wizard)
Jaagrath Kreeg (male Ogre Barbarian)
Lucrecia (Lamia matriarch rogue)
Wet Pappa Grazuul (scrag fighter)
Briselda, Grelthaga and Larastina (Annis Hag Coven)
Barl Breakbones (Stone Giant Necromancer)
Best Battle or Scene:
Mammy Graul and her sons
The traps at the Graul Farm
Rescuing the Black Arrows from Biggin' the advanced-elite-funnel-web-spider
Infiltrating Fort Rannick
The Kreegs: Jaagrath, Dorella and Hookmaw
The rest of the Kreegs: Minktuck, Jolly and Karly-Lop
The nymph Myriana in Whitewillow
Wet Pappa Grazuul
The Hag's Coven and Lamatar
Barl and his Bodyguard
Best Location:
1. Fort Rannick 6
2. The Graul Farm 3
3. Skull's Crossing 1
Most memorable Villain:
1. Mammy Graul 6
2. Barl Breakbones 2
2.Briselda, Grelthaga and Larastina 2
3. Wet Papa Grazuul 1
Best Battle or Scene:
1. Mammy Graul and her sons 3
1. Infiltrating Fort Rannick 3
2. The Hag's Coven and Lamatar 2
3. The traps at the Graul Farm 1
3. Rescuing the Black Arrows from Biggin'1
3. Wet Pappa Grazuul 1