Here’s some real punk for you;
FU old people!, anyone who grew up and survived punk aren’t real punks because you grew up and joined the society you were rebelling against. Punk is a state of mind not a narrowly defined type of music and FU for trying to make it that way.
The punk bands you remember from your rebel youth can never happen again because those same bands that were giving the finger to the establishment are now owned and promoted by the establishment and you have become the establishment. Any band you listen to that doesn’t measure up to your youthful ideas of punk is punk because punk is the discarded and spurned music of the young and now you are old you no longer understand this.
Heh. Cute. The reality is this:
Nothing new under the sun. The problem isn't digging the style or the music, the problem is thinking y'all are doing something other than aping the past. Do. Your. Own. Thing. And stop with the whiny vocals. And, please, do without all of the niceties "the establishment" have provided you, like your parents' money, I-pods, and the computer you're telling us old school dudes to "FU" on. Also, um, stop being so one-sided about who's evil in government. Jello Biafra, for example, didn't care about the (d) or the (r), if you were a pol, you were a pos, period.
Same as you did?
Here’s some real punk for you;
FU old people!, anyone who grew up and survived punk aren’t real punks because you grew up and joined the society you were rebelling against. Punk is a state of mind not a narrowly defined type of music and FU for trying to make it that way.
Heya Xabulba you're under the same curse as we "old people" are, once you have to start earning money to survive and your rebellious phase is no longer being funded by mum & dad other considerations take priority
Heh. Cute. The reality is this:
Nothing new under the sun. The problem isn't digging the style or the music, the problem is thinking y'all are doing something other than aping the past. Do. Your. Own. Thing. And stop with the whiny vocals. And, please, do without all of the niceties "the establishment" have provided you, like your parents' money, I-pods, and the computer you're telling us old school dudes to "FU" on. Also, um, stop being so one-sided about who's evil in government. Jello Biafra, for example, didn't care about the (d) or the (r), if you were a pol, you were a pos, period.
Same as you did?
HD there is good stuff out there just dont look for it in the mainstream because you are going to be disappointed every time. The establishment (mum & dad) provided me with the cash to rebel - got the money for my stereo, walkman, tapes, records & CDs from them.
James pulls on his Lionel Richie "All Night Long" t-shirt and Members Only jacket, stares at the clock until it's cool again.
|
Here’s some real punk for you;
FU old people!, anyone who grew up and survived punk aren’t real punks because you grew up and joined the society you were rebelling against. Punk is a state of mind not a narrowly defined type of music and FU for trying to make it that way.
Heya Xabulba you're under the same curse as we "old people" are, once you have to start earning money to survive and your rebellious phase is no longer being funded by mum & dad other considerations take priority
Heh. Cute. The reality is this:
Nothing new under the sun. The problem isn't digging the style or the music, the problem is thinking y'all are doing something other than aping the past. Do. Your. Own. Thing. And stop with the whiny vocals. And, please, do without all of the niceties "the establishment" have provided you, like your parents' money, I-pods, and the computer you're telling us old school dudes to "FU" on. Also, um, stop being so one-sided about who's evil in government. Jello Biafra, for example, didn't care about the (d) or the (r), if you were a pol, you were a pos, period.
Same as you did?HD there is good stuff out there just dont look for it in the mainstream because you are going to be disappointed every time. The establishment (mum & dad) provided me with the cash to rebel - got the money for my stereo, walkman, tapes, records & CDs from them.
Saw a good ska/punk band from South Carolina the other day in fact. I know there's still good stuff out there.
My point has much more to do with the "motivational" that Shiny posted than anything else.
|
|
HD there is good stuff out there just dont look for it in the mainstream because you are going to be disappointed every time. The establishment (mum & dad) provided me with the cash to rebel - got the money for my stereo, walkman, tapes, records & CDs from them.
Saw a good ska/punk band from South Carolina the other day in fact. I know there's still good stuff out there.
My point has much more to do with the "motivational" that Shiny posted than anything else.
I wish I could get out there and see shows, but a). I have classes to get to, and b). the city of Savannah not only classifies Straight Edge (which is NOT a set of rules) as a gang, but has some f~%~ing bizarre ordnances regarding who's allowed into what show, and as a result, I'm boycotting the entire quote-unquote scene.
But, yeah, there is still good music out there.
|
|
HD there is good stuff out there just dont look for it in the mainstream because you are going to be disappointed every time. The establishment (mum & dad) provided me with the cash to rebel - got the money for my stereo, walkman, tapes, records & CDs from them.
Saw a good ska/punk band from South Carolina the other day in fact. I know there's still good stuff out there.
My point has much more to do with the "motivational" that Shiny posted than anything else.
I wish I could get out there and see shows, but a). I have classes to get to, and b). the city of Savannah not only classifies Straight Edge (which is NOT a set of rules) as a gang, but has some f@!@ing bizarre ordnances regarding who's allowed into what show, and as a result, I'm boycotting the entire quote-unquote scene.
But, yeah, there is still good music out there.
You should move here, go to the Art Institute and take in shows at Mangos and Notsuoh with me.
Why is it that every time I start a thread, it brings out the crazy in everyone?
Wait. Don't answer that.
~holds up a mirror in front of you and gives an innocent whistle~
|
|
You should move here, go to the Art Institute and take in shows at Mangos and Notsuoh with me.HD there is good stuff out there just dont look for it in the mainstream because you are going to be disappointed every time. The establishment (mum & dad) provided me with the cash to rebel - got the money for my stereo, walkman, tapes, records & CDs from them.
Saw a good ska/punk band from South Carolina the other day in fact. I know there's still good stuff out there.
My point has much more to do with the "motivational" that Shiny posted than anything else.
I wish I could get out there and see shows, but a). I have classes to get to, and b). the city of Savannah not only classifies Straight Edge (which is NOT a set of rules) as a gang, but has some f@!@ing bizarre ordnances regarding who's allowed into what show, and as a result, I'm boycotting the entire quote-unquote scene.
But, yeah, there is still good music out there.
Tell him how hot it is.
|
|
Tell him how hot it is.You should move here, go to the Art Institute and take in shows at Mangos and Notsuoh with me.HD there is good stuff out there just dont look for it in the mainstream because you are going to be disappointed every time. The establishment (mum & dad) provided me with the cash to rebel - got the money for my stereo, walkman, tapes, records & CDs from them.
Saw a good ska/punk band from South Carolina the other day in fact. I know there's still good stuff out there.
My point has much more to do with the "motivational" that Shiny posted than anything else.
I wish I could get out there and see shows, but a). I have classes to get to, and b). the city of Savannah not only classifies Straight Edge (which is NOT a set of rules) as a gang, but has some f@!@ing bizarre ordnances regarding who's allowed into what show, and as a result, I'm boycotting the entire quote-unquote scene.
But, yeah, there is still good music out there.
It is hot, but that just makes all the hotties wear less clothing....
It is hot, but that just makes all the hotties wear less clothing....Hmmm... For some reason, all the Texan girls at SCAD are brainless loudmouths. Easy on the eyes, but not on the ears.
Are they wearing Minor Threat t-shirts?
Hmmm, semi-quoting type o negative. Scary.SHE'S WEARING A f*@!ING MINOR THREAT T-SHIRT! WHAT THE f*@!!?I'm sorry, Mr. Shiny. She knows not what she does.
I hope I haven't done anything horrible by doing this.
Someone wake me up when she starts rocking a Gorilla Biscuits hoodie or a Bikini Kill tee. I'll be in the waiting room.
Of course, given the abstinence-bent in the Twilight books (at least the first one, probably wrong about the rest) straight-edge vampires make some sense.
|
|
Johnny Rotten, selling out and doing butter commercial
That dude sold out before I was born. I'm still a down with the Sex Pistols, though.
|
Here’s some real punk for you;
FU old people!, anyone who grew up and survived punk aren’t real punks because you grew up and joined the society you were rebelling against. Punk is a state of mind not a narrowly defined type of music and FU for trying to make it that way.
The punk bands you remember from your rebel youth can never happen again because those same bands that were giving the finger to the establishment are now owned and promoted by the establishment and you have become the establishment. Any band you listen to that doesn’t measure up to your youthful ideas of punk is punk because punk is the discarded and spurned music of the young and now you are old you no longer understand this.
I'll one up you!!!
FU kids!!!
The old punk died because the majority of them grew up and learned enough to figure out they were wrong. The next generation, as always, just repeats the same mistakes of ignorance until eventually, most of them stop being ignorant.True punk always fails. Most punks are just too young to understand it.
I heard it much simpler but very much the same:
If you are not a Liberal when you turn 18 you have no PASSION.
If you are not a Conservative when you turn 30 then you have no SENSE
|
|
Here’s some real punk for you;
FU old people!, anyone who grew up and survived punk aren’t real punks because you grew up and joined the society you were rebelling against. Punk is a state of mind not a narrowly defined type of music and FU for trying to make it that way.
The punk bands you remember from your rebel youth can never happen again because those same bands that were giving the finger to the establishment are now owned and promoted by the establishment and you have become the establishment. Any band you listen to that doesn’t measure up to your youthful ideas of punk is punk because punk is the discarded and spurned music of the young and now you are old you no longer understand this.
I'll one up you!!!
FU kids!!!
The old punk died because the majority of them grew up and learned enough to figure out they were wrong. The next generation, as always, just repeats the same mistakes of ignorance until eventually, most of them stop being ignorant.True punk always fails. Most punks are just too young to understand it.
I heard it much simpler but very much the same:
If you are not a Liberal when you turn 18 you have no PASSION.
If you are not a Conservative when you turn 30 then you have no SENSE
It was Winston Churchill, and it was "heart" and "brains" ;)
Senior Software Developer
|
Johnny Rotten, selling out and doing butter commercialThat dude sold out before I was born. I'm still a down with the Sex Pistols, though.
Well, yeah, probably. I'm still gonna play me a little black rubber bag and/or rise tonight if I can dig out the vinyl, though. (Have no idea what he's done since then besides that butter commercial, maybe he sold out even bigger than that... but that white PiL still rocked last time I checked.)
|
|
Well, yeah, probably. I'm still gonna play me a little black rubber bag and/or rise tonight if I can dig out the vinyl, though. (Have no idea what he's done since then besides that butter commercial, maybe he sold out even bigger than that... but that white PiL still rocked last time I checked.)Johnny Rotten, selling out and doing butter commercialThat dude sold out before I was born. I'm still a down with the Sex Pistols, though.
Was that the generic album labeled Cassette/LP/CD depending on the media it was sold on?
|
Senior Software Developer
|
Was that the generic album labeled Cassette/LP/CD depending on the media it was sold on?
Probably. The copy I have is labeled "album." Given how far back it was in my collection I'd estimate I haven't played it in probably a dozen years or so.
I'm listening it to now, and I gotta say, I think my positive impressions of the record revolve mostly around the lyrics. "Anger is an energy," etc. The recording itself sounds incredibly dated/eighties -- it could be a Duran Duran album sonically.
|
|
Was that the generic album labeled Cassette/LP/CD depending on the media it was sold on?Probably. The copy I have is labeled "album." Given how far back it was in my collection I'd estimate I haven't played it in probably a dozen years or so.
I'm listening it to now, and I gotta say, I think my positive impressions of the record revolve mostly around the lyrics. "Anger is an energy," etc. The recording itself sounds incredibly dated/eighties -- it could be a Duran Duran album sonically.
Yeah, PiL definitely wasn't hard. Kinda scratched my head for a while when they came out.
Thank heavens the DKs were lynching landlords around that time...
Was that the generic album labeled Cassette/LP/CD depending on the media it was sold on?Probably. The copy I have is labeled "album." Given how far back it was in my collection I'd estimate I haven't played it in probably a dozen years or so.
I'm listening it to now, and I gotta say, I think my positive impressions of the record revolve mostly around the lyrics. "Anger is an energy," etc. The recording itself sounds incredibly dated/eighties -- it could be a Duran Duran album sonically.
Yeah, PiL definitely wasn't hard. Kinda scratched my head for a while when they came out.
Thank heavens the DKs were lynching landlords around that time...
My local oldies radio station plays a lot of the old punk bands as part of it's line up, no DKs or Surf Punks though.
Why is it that every time I start a thread, it brings out the crazy in everyone?
Wait. Don't answer that.
Well this thread in particular is pretty easy to pin. Any time you bring up anything about punk being dead, or whatever, and there is anyone that has any kind of connection with it, there's always gonna be a heavy debate.
At least this one hasn't gotten too rabid.
"Punk" is nothing but death... and crime... and the rage of a beast.
-Batman
My girlfriend said she saw the guy from Twilight wearing a painted leather with The Subhumans on it, so umm.... yeah, it seems there's a trend there that I don't like.I don't care for it much, either. Especially when a girl wearing a Specials shirt (I presume from Hot Topic) came into the deli I manage and asked who performed the song that was playing (we run my mp3 player through the system, radio sucks).
The band playing? Yeah, it was The Specials.
Ha! I hope you laughed hysterically for a couple of minutes... and then told her to get out.
Seriously, punk or not, people like that make me wonder why we can't figure a system to trim the gene pool a bit.
** spoiler omitted **
I respect your punk roots. Now, isn't there a pbp that you're supposed to be playing catch-up in? [/snark]
Yeah... Haven't checked it in a couple of hours. I'm having trouble figuring out where to introduce my character. Hit me with a two-by-four, maybe?
I'll write you another intro and shoehorn you in. Ya know, a real punk wouldn't need such an easy slide into an adventure; he'd just kick ass and take names. ;-)
|
|
I'll write you another intro and shoehorn you in. Ya know, a real punk wouldn't need such an easy slide into an adventure; he'd just kick ass and take names. ;-)
Yeah... Haven't checked it in a couple of hours. I'm having trouble figuring out where to introduce my character. Hit me with a two-by-four, maybe?
Heh heh heh...
Thanks to this thread, I now have some "new" music on my Pandora station. Its been a while since I've listened to any DK...
|
|
Punk died around the time that Johnny and the boys were signing contracts with EMI (that's 1976, to save you a trip to wikipedia). I know a lot of people would like to believe otherwise, but everything else since has been about fashion. Sorry.Riiiight, so Bad Brains, Circle Jerks, Minor Threat, Black Flag, The Dead Kennedys, Subhumans UK, The Germs, Fear, Charged GBH, The Dicks, Exploited, M.D.C., etc, etc... all a bunch of poseurs. Yeah.
I didn't call anyone anything. An anti-establishment movement ends the moment it embraces the establishment. Past that you're just listening to echos.
Why is it that every time I start a thread, it brings out the crazy in everyone?
Wait. Don't answer that.
You called for a crazy person? I am here for the job. Where is the application that I have to fill out? I have references.
|
|
There wasn't any kind of coherent theme to any of the bands around prior to 1976. Even if there were, though, you're saying that the moment a member of a 'movement' (or whatever) goes mainstream the entire movement is over, which is silly, though maybe not as silly as giving quite that much power to the Sex Pistols.
Call it the way you see it, brother. I'm just saying- and keep in my that at 37, in my heart of hearts I'll always consider myself a punker, so I'm not talking from some academic, outsider point-of-view- at about seventeen I realized that the "punk" milieu was all about theatrics and Halloween costumes. As far as my argument, it's not uniquely mine. If you think that it's "silly", all I can offer in retort is, as one of my co-teachers would say, "whatevs."
|
I didn't call anyone anything. An anti-establishment movement ends the moment it embraces the establishment. Past that you're just listening to echos.Punk died around the time that Johnny and the boys were signing contracts with EMI (that's 1976, to save you a trip to wikipedia). I know a lot of people would like to believe otherwise, but everything else since has been about fashion. Sorry.Riiiight, so Bad Brains, Circle Jerks, Minor Threat, Black Flag, The Dead Kennedys, Subhumans UK, The Germs, Fear, Charged GBH, The Dicks, Exploited, M.D.C., etc, etc... all a bunch of poseurs. Yeah.
I think it ends once you call it a "movement".
To me it was about rejecting everything and more akin to social terrorism. It offended the sensibilities of the age because it didn't embrace the false utopia being pushed in the late 70 early 80s. It was about doing the things you're not supposed to do or at least all the things you weren't suppose to like - being an upstanding citizen an all.I think like many things, after some time it became stagnant and got co-opted by leftist as a social "movement" and then some years later when it became acceptable and eventually more mainstream (marketable). It wasn't meant to live, in fact it was probably stillborn - we just took some time looking at its corpse - then it was all over.
Oh yeah
Oi!
|
|
Let's see, if we just look at the proto-punks (MC5, the Stooges, etc), they weren't trying to start much of anything. Later, the Ramones just wanted to play straight up rock and roll without the pretenses of arena rock, again, they weren't trying to be anything. The Cramps were just being silly.
Blame the Brits for turning it into a fashion/political "movement". they were always way too self conscious about everything anyway. Well, specifically blame Malcolm McLaren. He was into creating scenes (New York Dolls, Sex Pistols) and only cared about the marketing. Heck, I'm glad the Chili Peppers said no thanks to his management, it staved off their sell out moment for another six years or so...
Meh.