Who would YOU want to play your PbP character(s) in a movie?

[The Eldritch Mr. Shiny]

This was just something random that popped into my head at 2 AM.

Mine:

Craig Conway (Doomsday) as Keegan Cawley
Adam Baldwin (Serenity) as Corvin Killgannon
Kevin Durand (Walking Tall) as Radik Aurel
Voice of David Hewlett (Cube) as Brick
Stephen McHattie (Shoot 'em Up) as Rackham Pulsifer
Sean Faris (The Glass Eye) as Mike O'Neill

[Heathansson]

Pierce Brosnan as Rodergo Xativa (The Matador blew my mind)
as Schenker? IDK; he's not leading man material, and I can't think of a fitting character actor offhand.
Hudak? again, IDK. He's a total derp wad; again not leading man material. Maybe that older brother from Weird Science. (edit) Bill Paxton.

[The Eldritch Mr. Shiny]

Heathansson wrote:

as Schenker? IDK; he's not leading man material, and I can't think of a fitting character actor offhand.

Flea, maybe?

[Heathansson]

I thought of Flea, but naa....I base him loosely off of Rorscach from the Watchmen, blended with Ukko (Slaine mac Roth's vulgar dwarven sidekick) from the Slaine comics.

[Heathansson]

For Hudak, Clancy Brown, the Kurgan from Highlander. He could do durpy enough. I envisioned Hudak as this Conan-type, but without the charisma; sorta durpier than Fafhrd. Like a big goofy great dane pup that, though he is going to be an extremely powerful beast, still doesn't quite fit into his legs just yet.

[Heathansson]

I really want to see who fakey picks for Riese.

[Fake Healer]

Heathansson wrote:

I really want to see who fakey picks for Riese.

Pierce Brosnan, smarmy accent and all. I have seen him do some really good stuck-up roles.

[Fake Healer]

Sayid from Lost for Aref in Kruelaid's game.

[Fake Healer]

Dravite reminds me of a long-haired, bearded Sean Sherk from the UFC if he was shorter and wider, but mostly for his violence and look, not any way he acts.
For an actor I would have to go with Mel Gibson.

[Fake Healer]

Terin the Beast is Jason Statham or Hugh Jackman.

[Mothman]

Anarath Coldblood – Johnnie Depp
Valessa Marr – Maggie Q
Elisile Starbrow – Keira Knightly
Thorn of Clovenwood – Jason Statham
Beldan Vale – Justin Long
Dave Judd – Jesse Spencer

Not sure about Lightbringer, Eldin Farstrider, or Daetha Tain

[Heathansson]

Oooh, now I want John Malkovich to be Rodergo.

[Mothman]

Heathansson wrote:

Oooh, now I want John Malkovich to be Rodergo.

I can sort of see Pierce Brosnan doing the voice of Lightbringer, so if John's playing Rod, maybe Pierce will be free to do LB?

[Heathansson]

That'll work.

[Fake Healer]

Heathansson wrote:

Pierce Brosnan as Rodergo Xativa (The Matador blew my mind)

as Schenker? IDK; he's not leading man material, and I can't think of a fitting character actor offhand.
Hudak? again, IDK. He's a total derp wad; again not leading man material. Maybe that older brother from Weird Science. (edit) Bill Paxton.

I think of Schenker as Roddy Piper.

[Heathansson]

I gotta watch more rasslin.

[Gavgoyle]

I would pick...

William Fitchner to act as Vergor Fenstrider, the swamp druid in the crocodile-skin leather armor.
Tom Welling (Clark Kent in Smallville) for Kells Gryffoncrest, the slightly excitable paladin of liberty.

[Luke]

I only have one character in a PbP - Shagraat the hobgoblin monk. I'm thinking Jackie Chan in a gorilla suit. I was thinking Jet Li at first, but only Jackie could pull off those moves in a gorilla suit - with a ladder no less!

[Kirth Gersen]

Hellard Byzenkampf - Not Jude Law. That's all I ask. You can get Danny Glover, or Renee Zellwiger, or Bugs Bunny, but just not Jude Law.

Sorry, that just popped into my head.

[TwiceBorn]

Mothman wrote:

Anarath Coldblood – Johnnie Depp

Valessa Marr – Maggie Q
Elisile Starbrow – Keira Knightly
Thorn of Clovenwood – Jason Statham
Beldan Vale – Justin Long
Dave Judd – Jesse Spencer

Not sure about Lightbringer, Eldin Farstrider, or Daetha Tain

Mothman, why not tell us how you picture the casts for your Age of Darkness and Whispering Cairn PbPs? I'm curious... ;-)

[The Eldritch Mr. Shiny]

Vilya the Taker - Barbara Mori

[David Fryer]

Ronin-Jason Statham or Daniel Craig
Perigia-Jewel Staite
Dirdelle-Gemma Arterton
Garath Darkstalker-Either Taylor Kitsch or Daniel Henney

[The Eldritch Mr. Shiny]

Z-Day (Kruelaid)
Joe Flanigan (Stargate Atlantis) as Sgt. Patrick Curtin
Hannah Spearritt (Primeval) as Samantha Bastian
Steve Talley (American Pie: the Naked Mile) as Mike O'Neill
Jesse Spencer (House) as Dave Judd
Paul Campbell (Severed) as Cord Vogel
Alessandro Juliani (Battlestar Galactica) as Juan Rico

Grimmbold Manor (Arctaris)
Tahmoh Penikett (Battlestar Galactica) as Corvin Killgannon
Reece Thompson (Stargate Atlantis) as Tzoltan Devreen
Rodrigo Santoro (Redbelt) as Anarath Coldblood
(miniature) Ben Browder (Farscape) as Dohrlok
Ben Foster (Alpha Dog) as Tsiilmas Mithalvarin

Dead Reckoning (Kruelaid)
Christopher Heyerdahl (Sanctuary) as Rackham Pulsifer
Naveen Andrews (Grindhouse) as Aref Sari Samokh
Callum Keith Rennie (Tin Man) as the Deceiver
Tony Lee (Lost) as Jon Qiang
Noah Danby (Paiinkiller Jane) as Sydley Hentooth
Blake Bashoff (Lost) as Ryor

False Hope (Fake Healer)
Craig Conway (Doomsday) as Keegan Cawley (featuring Rekha Sharma as Keegan's lady)
(miniature) Aaron Douglas (Battlestar Galactica) as Faldor O'Gitoresh
Daniel Cudmore (Alone in the Dark) as Jaden Thorm
(miniature) Ryan Robbins (Sanctuary) as Effan Effluvium
Jeremy Howard (Accepted) as Hosz Ferryman
Sean Maher (Firefly) as Raphael D'Adarrin

The Fine Art of Reciprocity (mwbeeler)
The Rock (Scorpion King) as Holdrus Rippor
"Flea" (The Big Lebowski) as Shenker
Kevin Durand (Walking Tall) as Radik Aurel
(voice of) Torri Higginson (Stargate Atlantis) as Kha-Chik-Chik-Ka
(voice of) Henry Rollins (Johnny Mnemonic) as Skarsnikt
(voice of) David Hewlett (A Dog's Breakfast) as Kirrish-Kreshk-Skiklik
Alaina Kalanj (Painkiller Jane) as Marada
(miniature) Jamie Kennedy (Harold and Kumar) as Aso
Robin Dunne (Sanctuary) as Faindraic Fellstar
Christopher Judge (Stargate SG-1) as MalaKi

Savage Tide (mwbeeler)
Jason Statham (The Transporter) as Terin Talonshift
Stephen Lobo (Painkiller Jane) as Marius Hawk
Aaron Stanford (X2) as Ardan
Ryan Reynolds (Blade: Trinity) as Seann Eoghan
Scott Adkins (Pit Fighter) as Tyndal Maelglum

[lastknightleft]

Edward Norton would be about perfect for Gavrin Norbera, gnome monk.