anum militus wrote:
they were flying a flag, but it almost seemed like they were wanting to discuss something. I know that if our paladin killed one and he wasn't evil and we attacked unprovoked then she would be in a little trouble. I asked the DM about this and he didn't say they were evil, he just said that she didn't actually attack anything, she failed her balance check on a plank to board the other ship real bad and fell in the water. I was just thinking though. This ship had no supplies, nothing at all, and was in bad shape.
They were evil and wanted to steal your stuff, not ask for help.