The black raven's page

Oh. You are that one :-(

Saw a 3P item ;-)

I am sorry, but the IP infringement was honestly better.

I think we need to consider the whole DQ+Cull percentage, as this was the target number the host likely aimed for. And I believe the number of votes was sufficiently high that we can rely on the time needed for the first cull to extrapolate the time needed for the second cull.

We started from 700 items, we are now around 550 items post-cull and I believe we will finish a bit over 100 at the end of the voting. Not sure how it translates in the time required for the next cull though.

I just saw the item that speaks of itself. Very funny I must say :-)

And ... it's a Keep too. Huge potential.

An affordable consumable that has slang for itself in its description...hilarious and definitely a keeper.

I just saw it too. Very funny I must say :-)

And ... it's a Keep too. Huge potential.

Do we know the overall survival rate ? This could help us guess when the next cull will happen ;-)

Interesting item : imaginative and useful in several different ways. A bit too outlandish for me to Keep, but a good item nonetheless.

Interesting item : imaginative and useful in several different ways. A bit too outlandish for me to Keep, but a good item nonetheless.

My item recently appeared on the list. I may yet recover from the Snark's influence :-P

Ooh. So that Occult item survived the cull. But then so did the unformatted one of the previous pairing :-/

You put a blank line that eases reading. This is almost the only reason I upvote you :-(

This item fits my definition of overpowered. That one on the other hand goes far beyond it in realms where madness resides

Now just might be the perfect moment for Belkar to come back by some outlandish means and

I think I will always downvote you. Especially after the cull.

Spotted another survivor.

And yet another one ;-)

This is cool. Too utilitarian for a Keep, but cool nonetheless ;-)

This is cool. Too utilitarian for a Keep, but cool nonetheless ;-)

The snark is getting too much of a hold on my soul :-/

This aura and this slot do not exist in Pathfinder. How did you survive the cull ?

Talk about keeping the tension high to the end.

Well done indeed.

BTW : love some of the justifications. Would Balder be the god of sorcerers perchance ?

NEW ONE

Useless ? vs Unusable ? Fight ?

Gross item wins against goody two-shoes

Nice Cat you got there, though OP for its price IMO

Metagame divining item. But so innovative that it's a keep :-)

Two divining items. But the one on the left is far better IMO. And Keep :-)

Spotted another survivor.

I do not like you, but at least your designer is imaginative. Not so the other one.

The office item did survive the cull :-))

This is excellent. The last ability is likely OP for the item's price, but the whole is excellent. Keep.

This is excellent. The last ability is likely OP for the item's price, but the whole is excellent. Keep.

Item of totally not snakes, your infringement on a well-known IP is thinly veiled

Item of not dying vs Item of getting better. Fight ?

Hide or healed. Your choice

So many monstrous faces out there. Halloween came early for some reason.

Hope springs eternal ;-)

all shields survived the cull... tip for next year make a shield

Tip for next year : make a Superstar shield ;-)

The black raven wrote:

Your item is only useful for a single race ? Bad design IMO :-/

Devil's Advocate: How is that different than the multitude of items only usable by a specific class? Or do you think those are poorly designed as well?

You can always take a level in almost any class. You usually cannot change your race that easily ;-)

Even if this strange word exists, there is a usual way to describe this effect and it sure as H does not use this word.

And ... another one made it through :-)

Both items are not good. This one's formatting is very slightly better. Upvoted :-(

Dear Customer Service,

I have not used my main alias for years now.

Is it possible to switch it with this alias I am using, which I constantly use in the forums ?

Best regards,

The black raven

You do not follow the proper formatting. What was you secret to survive the cull ?

Unstoppable attack item vs Unbreachable defense item. I expect the deflagration to wipe out a quarter of the galaxy.

Your item is only useful for a single race ? Bad design IMO :-/

The black raven wrote:

Here's hoping to Star :-)

Congrats! (It's showing under your main Berod alias.)

Thanks a lot AS. Too bad that I have not used that alias for years ;-P

Duel of two items that I just saw a few minutes ago paired against other items. The one I upvoted is better than the one I downvoted. Yay for internal consistency.

I finally found the item that closely mimics my entry; and it's actually pretty good. Perhaps I'm just biased? Anyway, it got my vote. Now if I could just come across my submission.

I saw that item too. Yours is decidedly better IMO ;-)

The deciding factor was the Slot correctly used. And not between 2 superstar items :-(