
Sakri |
There's a number of things at play here.
#1 How many characters are in your party? Paizo APs are built for four-man parties. If you're playing with more than that there's going to be more buffs going around, more resources to spare, etc.
#2 What method are you using for stat generation? If you're rolling, stop. If you're using point buy, drop it to 15. Paizo APs are built assuming 15 point buy characters.
#3 How optimized are your characters? How optimized are their tactics? Paizo APs are built assuming a moderate level of optimization. If your players are building character at peak or near peak effectiveness, they're going to crush most encounters. You need to either work with them to tone their character down, do the work to buff/rework most of the encounters, or accept that they're going to breeze through the AP.
1. 5 characters but most of the time, we have only 4 players present.
2. We used 15 point PB.
3. I'd say, the characters are semi-optimized but not hc-optimized. Furthermore, note that there are no full-casters in the party, which I understand, are more powerful than other characters.