My group has been having a debate about the two weapon fighting feat. Let's say the rogue has the feat and has a weapon in each hand. On his turn he moves 20 feet and then attacks as a standard action. Does he suffer the penalties from the two weapon fighting feat, even though he only makes one attack with his primary weapon?
My players say no, but I say yes because he has a weapon in each hand and he is utilizing that style of fighting - even if he only gets one attack.
Now take it another step. Suppose the rogue drops one weapon or it breaks or he only has one weapon available. In this case I would argue that he can't use a two weapon style of fighting, if he only has one weapon, so he would not be penalized for two weapon fighting.
Any insight would be helpful - I'm tired of having this argument every week :-(
