Chris Mortika wrote:
A number of reviewers have likened Northwest Smith to the likes of Indiana Jones or Han Solo.
I'm not seeing it.
I have to agree. Though I actually only see one person in this thread likening him to Han Solo, that's certainly the impression you would get from blurbs about Smith being an "intergalactic smuggler" and "daring spaceman". I've read the Indy comparison somewhere else, can't recall where, though. But the only similarity I see with Indiana Jones is the names...
The thing is that both Han and Indy are action heroes, and these are in no way action stories. They're all internal, there are few to none external events going on. And even though I like them, they're fine pieces of writing, reading them all so close together unfortunately highlights that they're all pretty much the same. They all deal with Smith getting possessed, hypnotized, enthralled or otherwise mind****ed, and how he struggles free from whatever's got him hooked this time around.
Now, to play the devil's advocate for a bit... The narration in the stories does make it clear that most of the time Smith actually is a physical, extroverted, take-charge kind of guy. Just not in the timeframes of these particular stories. It's as if someone wrote stories about Han Solo, but not when he's fighting stormtroopers or dodging imperial cruisers, instead focusing on the times he's sitting in a corner of a bar having a morose drink by himself. And to Smith's credit, the reason that he manages to break free of the various sirens where lesser men have failed, is that at the deepest, darkest core of his being he's just one mean bastard.