I have an order that arrived back in October that doesn't show as shipped, it is still "pending". It did arrive just fine. Almost a non-issue, but next time someone is cleaning up miscellaneous order issues, that one is ripe for the picking. Maybe a bug to look at.
Thanks for bringing this to our attention. This was a known issue with the Product Catalogue during the October subscription run. I have poked the order and the display issue should be resolved.