So I have 2 devout followers of Gozreh aboard. A druid and a sor. I am trying to figure how I should play this.
1-Plugg and Scourge bust it up.
2-Plugg and Scourge have lackeys start a problem and bring down judgment that turns people against the PCs.
3-Let it run just like any other night and give them a chance to use diplomacy.
4-Have Plugg start to bust it up but have Harrigan intervene putting Plugg into overdrive in hatred for the PCs.