My friend just ran Port Godless the other day, and there was a bit of controversy.
He was running the end boss - wizard with summoning spells. The wizard was invisible, and summoned a vargoulle. Then the next turn summoned a tiger (with infernal template).
Apparently the tiger is on an alternate summoning list, but the GM had the AP module where it came from (#53 Tide of Honor). According to additional resources, that is allowed for players.
The players protested that the tiger was illegal, and eventually my friend changed the summon to a celestial lion.
I would like some clarification about whether or not what my friend was trying to do was illegal, and specifically why.
A few things to note:
- I have not read Port Godless, I don't know the BBEGs tactics, etc.
- I do not own AP #53 Tide of Honor, and I haven't looked at the list.
- Additional resources for PFS Organized Play says the list is allowed, but does not list any restrictions (like deity, for instance)
- I searched for this topic before posting, but my forum skillz are not very good, so I apologize if this was covered somewhere else.
Thank you