So, not too long ago i had a game session with my friends and older brother, all was going well until tragedy struck and one pc (my friend) up and murdered another pc (my brother) with little warning. Now inevitably the game devolved into a arguing match of "wtf" both in and out of game and both the murderer's character and the player left in a huff. I'm posting this cause i can't wrap my head around the situation and figured some of you would find the story entertaining and would have some comments on the situation.
So here are the details: the party consisted of five adventurers all of good alignment, a mute human female monk 10th lvl about 4 ft tall, a saytre bard 7th lvl, a human restless soul ranger 11th lvl (me), a halfelf sorcerer with gold dragon bloodline lvl 7(the murdered), and a human barbarian duskblade 9th lvl (the murderer) The barbarian is just smart enough to get away being a duskblade, but the story behind him gets slightly complicated as follows: his tribe worshipped thor, and in the storyline we had thor had died, and to keep the people from going insane, the shamans of his tribe turned to arcane power to hide their lost divine powers. They had managed to keep up this charade for quite some time, and when arcane leanings were discovered in the barbarian they took him under their tutelage and taught him more powers, and told him he was gifted by the gods, and somewhere along the line, he came to believe he was the reincarnation of thor who was not yet dead, and through some adventuring hated dragons.
Now the encounter goes as such. Our party of monk, ranger and barbarian comes to the rescue of a caravan being escorted by the bard and the sorcerer, standard save the day and party hook up after final escort to town, sorcerer shows off his fire breath to impress the party. On our way to the next encounter up in the mountains at a monastery, the barbarian decided to have some fun and puts dancing lights around the rangers head as a prank which gathers hilarity from reaction, the sorcerer seeing good fun to be had, uses drench to get the barbarian wet.
And this is the fateful moment, the barbarian, hearing the casting of the wicked dragon like creature and then getting soaked turns with out any warning and throws his powerfully enchanted warhammer at the sorcerer using the lightning spell stored in the weapon, hits, crits and rolls max damage on weapon and high damage on spell flat out killing the sorcerer in one hit. Now i know that im a bit biased by the fact it was my brother that was murdered by what i think was a lousy reason so i figured i would ask: was there a bit of over reaction on the barbarian? Or was he justified murdering as he did. And how the hell do you keep from having a in party feud or fight? We haven't gamed since as a group.