| hazardousindex |
I just cannot, in my mind, reconcile the fact that Antimagic Field cancels out all Supernatural abilities. I want to houserule that it only affects spells and spell-like abilities, but I am encountering a lot of opposition from my players on this. My reasons are twofold:
1) Flavor: Antimagic Field canceling Supernaturals doesn't fit the "flavor" of many Pathfinder monsters. It blocking a dragon's breath is a major example of this. Another is the disappearance of incorporeal undead, and another is the negation of monster damage reduction. Finally, channel energy is perhaps my biggest flavor problem, as I always took that healing/harm to represent a deity's intervention, and the gods' power is so much more than simple "magic." As written, this spell should be called "Antifantasy Field," as it strips most iconic fantasy characters and monsters of not only magic, but also all of their unique abilities that make them fun, interesting, or challenging to encounter.
2) Power: The spell is only a 6th level spell and, as written, I believe it is too powerful. Nullifying spells and spell-like abilities is powerful enough on its own to warrant a 6th level spell, even considering that the character who cast the spell can no longer cast. (Though they could buff the party considerably beforehand.) Allowing supernaturals nullifies too many abilities in addition to spells and spellcasting. It turns the spell into a must-have, which, to me, means there is a balance issue.
My players believe (almost to a fault) that the rules of Pathfinder are fair and balanced at all times. They don't like it when I houserule powerful spells and abilities. Ordinarily, I would acquiesce to the rules as written, but my gut is telling me not to on this one. It doesn't seem balanced, and it doesn't seem like it preserves the flavor of the game. Not to mention that where there's smoke, there's fire, and a lot of people on these boards seem to dislike/feel uncomfortable about this spell.
So what do you guys think? Is it balanced as-is? Is my change an acceptable house rule, or is there something else I should consider?