| Vimes |
| 3 people marked this as a favorite. |
-Let the crimelord go but willingly allow the npc family to die (definitely evil imo)
That's not evil, it's the crimelord choice. Unless he wants them to die, it's naive at worst.
I would say killing the crimelord would not be evil. Maybe offering him to fight for his life allowing to use a weapon would be the most paladin thing to do. Another option would be to let the crimelord go and stay with the family until they are attacked, and kill the atackers in self defense. Also, you can tie and carry the crimelord as a prisoner until you find something better to do with her.
Best thing for you is the first one, I think. Challenge her to a duel, end her life there in the most paladin way possible without changing your alignement.
But as others already said, it is definitely not deserving a good-to-evil change. To neutral, at worst, and still I would say it would be a warn at most. If it is against the deity of the character, I would make them do something for redemption or face the consquences, but definitely not making the character illegal.