Hello there
Been trying to find a post with this discussion, but all I could find was people talking about if you can be a cleric and an atheist..
But the thing is: in the game I'm playing at the moment, me and a player playing a cleric got to talking about the gods and planes, just to get some talk going so he had a better understanding of how the greater universe worked.
But we then started talking about one of the other players who is an atheist. She believes in the gods, but does not worship them in anyway and don't believe/want them to, have any influence in her life.. Which means, she doesn't want the cleric's blessings :P
So, what would happen to such atheists when they die?
Step 1. They die
Step 2. Go to the Boneyard to recieve judgement
Step 3. Profit!! They are sent to the place that has "dibs" on their soul, unless they have performed really poorly (you might be worshiping Abadar, but whats this!! You have sold bad wares, cheated on deals and killed small baby bunnies out of boredom?!.. That's one ticket to hell for ya' mate).
So, what if you were a person who generally was a good but did not worship any gods? Would you be allowed into heaven or another good plane, or would you simply stay in the Boneyard for all eternity?
I just can't imagine the later, since people would know this would happen to them (the gods are VERY real in Golarion), and the good gods are good and I can't imagine that they would just say: "You might have saved countless lives, helped those in need at every opportunity, but you didn't want to play with us, so our doors are closed.." Not to mention Hell might be able to lure the soul into their fold instead..
Any thoughts on this subject would be appreciated..
Kind Regards
Neros