Munchabunch's page

- When attacking to grapple, the PC provokes an AoO. Can the "defender" use a grapple as his AoO? (this then devolves into the vicious "last in, first out AoO Resolution" cycle, because his AoO attack provokes an AoO, which then means the "attacker" can launch a grapple-check as *his* AoO and it gets resolved, then up one iteration to the original defender's AoO, and then up to the original attack...)

According to the rules you can only make an AOO if you threathen a square with a meele weapon. Grappling is an unarmed attack and so does not threaten anyone. (That's why there's an AOO in the first place)

The Black Bard wrote:

Even in a town like Diamond Lake, who's gonna be interested in taking 100,000 iron balls off of your hands for the rate your asking? I think the concept buying in bulk would kill your profit ratio, or you could go the other way and take your time (maybe 2-3 years in game) selling them to the occasional blacksmith or such you meet along the way.

Logic in D&D is fine, as long as it's applied BOTH ways.

Given that it is a mining town, and has an iron mine, I would say plenty of people would be interested in purified iron to sell.

Or some of those mine managers would get jealous and locate that cache of iron balls and take it from you. Smenk would be first in line.

Well I think its a great idea. I'm developing a couple of weapons right now. One I'm using from the book (Divine Spark) and one I created myself using the rules, which I call Talon. Although I have 4 players, 2 of them had received heirlooms before starting on their adventure. They are now level 4 and they are about to find out about their Legacy Weapons.