| Mathematix |
Wow . . . it took me a while to realize it, but I guess I'm the bastard everyone is berating for calling them a "noob" since no one else mentioned starting players and the content of the book. Now that I realize that, I guess all I can say is that I didn't say that the book would only appeal to new players, nor that adding sample encounters and adventure ideas would only appeal to new players, or that there is something wrong with players that have been playing forever liking to have that content as well.
What I said is that such material is useful to someone that has never played the game before, that hasn't seen a ton of adventures in multiple editions, and that doesn't quite know where to start.
Your apology is appreciated Knight, but I think it was actually Balabanto that was expressing noobist attitudes. I've been playing since '79, DMing since '81, am clearly not a noob, and enjoyed the book.
WOTC puts out material that appeals to different people/groups for different reasons. If it doesn't appeal to you don't buy it. If they produce enough stuff with little appeal, simple economics takes care of the problem. The only thing I object to is the implication that because you (not talking to anyone specific here) don't like something, anyone who does is somehow inferior. Critique the material, not the individuals whose views might be different from your own.