Alien Gunfighter wrote:
What I really mean is a formula that would balance a minature's power with an appropriate point value cost, so the miniature would never go "out of style."
Even if errata had to be issued on various minis from time to time (changing their point value, their statistics, etc.), I think a formula would be better than retiring/rotating minis. Sure, I'd still use the minis for the RPG, but I'd really rather be stomping plastic monster butt with them.
Whoa, whoa, whoa there cowboy... There is no way that this would even be close to viable. Constantly changing errata and point values would make playing in a tournament way too much work for most players.
Here's the reality of DDM. As of today... CE is the best faction. Why? There are a few minis that are highly efficient in that faction... Orc Champion, Ogre Ravager, Red Samurai, Drider Sorceror, Orc Warrior, Abyssal Maw, Tiefling Captain, etc.
Does that mean that the other factions have absolutely no chance of winning at tournament? No... it just means that it's more difficult to win. I believe there was one CG band in the top 8 at the recent national tournament at GenCon. I'm pretty sure that was the only non-CE band in the top 8.
Does this require set rotation? Not really... CE would still be dominant without the Orc Warrior and Tiefling Captain (from the Harbinger set). It would likely remain dominant without Dragoneye also. Why? It's niche is high hitpoint, high damage figures. That's a tough combination to beat.
That said, the latest set gives a big boost to CG and also throws a couple of bones to LG and LE without giving CE a bunch more power (except the Chuul, which is pretty sweet). Even though CG has been made more viable, I still expect CE to dominate for a while.
The next set (Death Knell) should provide a needed boost to LE as it should be filled with undead... and it will also have some nice LE additions like the Beholder and the Mummy Lord.
The following set is rumored to be named Angelfire... which can only spell out a little bit of extra love for LG.
What does it all mean? It means that future sets should produce warband building options for all factions that are tournament worthy. I fully expect to see all of the factions represented in the top 8 at next year's national tournament.
We now bring you back to your regularly schedule topic. ;)
--sam