The Morphling wrote:
Using Smite Evil to cheat won't work. Because when you try to smite him, you will find out you no longer have the smite evil class feature. Or your spells. Or Lay on Hands.
Good luck with the Ogre, Mister Fighter-Without-Bonus-Feats.
Depends on how your GM defines the Paladin's code. Using Smite or LoH in a 1-on-1 non-magical duel isn't necessarily an evil act, especially if the paladin intends to save lives by doing so. (Especially if the Smite actually works, which raises the question of the other side of the Ogre's alignment. The default is Chaotic, which means that it probably wouldn't hesitate to cheat if it had to....) In fact, cheating in this instance would likely be a Chaotic act, for which there are no lasting repercussions.
The Code of Conduct section only mentions losing Paladin abilities if he willingly performs an evil act. Granted, the following paragraph refers to not lying or cheating, but it also mentions punishing those who harm or threaten innocents. (I'm assuming the people the Paladin is trying to save through this duel are innocent....) I actually have a problem with this paragraph, since by a strict interpretation, the Paladin cannot feint in combat (lying about where he's going to strike) or use flanking attacks (must act with honour, and ganging up on somebody could be considered dishonourable, especially if the target turns away, and the Paladin is now effectively stabbing it in the back!), neither of which seem to present any problems for most GMs.
(As an aside, if the Ogre tried to Intimidate the Paladin, would that cause the watching crowd to cry foul when the (Su) Aura of Courage activates, making Pally immune?)