Alright, I've followed this tread and it sure seems that the love Will-Hate Will groups are pretty evenly matched here.So, I'll throw my opinion int the ring.
I fall into the get rid of Will Save category. While I do find myself drawn to read the column every month, its more of that I-want-to-watch-a-train-wreck desire rather than gleaning anything from the column. After reading that column, I always feel pretty good. My life could be signficantly worse. I could be Will Wheaton.
I suggest Paizo dump Will Wheaton, dummp the guy who draws his picture on that column, and get rid of Downer while their at it.
Stockdale